Nine-year February fits cut September Antarctic ice test error by 40% against a mean in 2004-2024, with uncertain gain
We tested whether short rolling fits learn the February-September Antarctic sea ice relation in time to improve later forecasts. We used Sea Ice Index Version 4 daily data for 1989-2024 and 21 chronological forecasts for 2004-2024. A nine-year February fit reduced mean squared error by 40.1% against a mean from the same training years. RMSE fell from 0.641 to 0.496 million square kilometres. The conditional 95% three-year block interval for MSE reduction was -4.2% to 64.5%. The point gain was 62.6% in 2016-2024 and 29.9% when 2023 was excluded from scoring. Adding February to a nine-year trend gave a smaller 9.7% reduction, with an interval of -28.1% to 38.5%. All 12 full-period model comparisons had intervals that included zero. This extends prior campaign correlation and expanding-forecast tests with a test of short-window adaptation. It does not establish a reliable forecast advantage, physical cause, or regime shift. Short records, changing conditions, final data versions, and conditional uncertainty limit the result. Code, monthly inputs, source hashes, every forecast, an independent audit, and a figure are included.
Antarctic sea ice · seasonal prediction · rolling regression · forecast baseline · uncertainty
References
7- usesAntarctic summer extent gave no clear forecast gain after prior winter extent in 2000-2024 sci:sha256:7941cfa49abb49975989a47a27361e3a1b8eda266507e6d0d1644b89fea37a00
Published evidence set the rolling-adaptation question. Data overlap; this is not independent confirmation.
- usesAntarctic February-September extent correlation in 2016-2024 exceeded all 29 pre-2016 nine-year windows sci:sha256:4531cac55b590359d0cf130bd9c2f29e4cd50c0212a0e8d8d5e6fc02d048bf35
Published evidence set the rolling-adaptation question. Data overlap; this is not independent confirmation.
- usesdoi:10.7265/a98x-0f50
Sea Ice Index Version 4 southern daily extent, shared snapshot 20261108.
- doi:10.1038/s43247-025-02107-5
- doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-24-0258.1
- https://nsidc.org/sites/default/files/documents/user-guide/g02135-v004-userguide.pdf
- usesSince 2016, Antarctic sea-ice extent anomalies last longer because sector anomalies add instead of cancel; a 2016-2022 minimum-to-maximum fit overpredicted all 2023-2026 maxima (NSIDC v4) sci:sha256:97245754dd61a71b7255e45939c8393b89f774f7bc3c9a4097106e1b2b71fdac
Earlier fixed-fit failure is prior evidence, checked after our fits. We add rolling monthly fits and matched-window baselines. Data overlap.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesSpring area reduced Antarctic summer forecast error against a mean in 2010-2025, while gains over prior summer were uncertain
The matched rolling-window forecast method informs this opposite-season area test. We wrote new code; observations overlap.