The Mendota–Monona spring clarity peak gap increased by 15 days in selected 1996–2019 surveys
We tested whether the date of maximum observed spring water clarity changed in Lake Mendota relative to Lake Monona, Wisconsin, USA. We used open NTL-LTER Secchi data from 1995–2022. We matched April–July visits within seven days and required coverage at both ends of the window. The selected sample has 13 years in 1996–2008 and eight years in 2010–2019. We omitted transition year 2009. The mean Mendota-minus-Monona peak-date gap changed from −3.5 to +11.0 days. The change was +14.5 days, with a nominal 95% interval of +4.9 to +23.5 from blocks of three retained years. Calendar-year blocks gave +3.8 to +23.7. All visits and a common fortnightly grid gave changes of +15.6 and +9.8 days. With a three-day matching limit, the change was +6.8 days and its interval included zero. The median-gap change and a period effect conditional on the ice-off gap were also uncertain. No 2020–2022 year passed the main coverage rules. Earlier work already linked food webs to spring phase timing in these same lakes. This study adds a paired date estimate with explicit sampling checks and reproducible files. It describes selected sampled maxima; it does not identify the exact biological phase date or an invasion cause. The package preserves source data, hashes, provenance, code, all results, figures, and independent numerical checks.
lake ecology · Secchi depth · clear-water phase · phenology · sampling effort · Lake Mendota · Lake Monona · reproducibility
References
5- usesIn 2010–2014, Lake Monona lost as much May–September water clarity as Lake Mendota with 1–2% of its spiny water flea density; a Mendota-only clarity loss appeared only in 2015–2022 sci:sha256:790e581f9d80dbd9385844f30233f10a8453c1d6c51bb758e1df3d6bd56f6fba
We reuse its retained original Secchi and ice source files. Its seasonal mean-depth comparison motivates a new paired date metric. We do not reuse its code or derived results.
- usesdoi:10.6073/pasta/4c5b055143e8b7a5de695f4514e18142
NTL-LTER Secchi depth source release knb-lter-ntl.31.32.
- usesdoi:10.6073/pasta/6a95bee73799927cbafbf87393be7038
NTL-LTER ice source release knb-lter-ntl.33.40.
- doi:10.1002/lno.11584
Direct prior work on spring clear-water phase timing, duration, magnitude and environmental links in Mendota and Monona. We read its indexed abstract. We do not reproduce its estimator.
- doi:10.1073/pnas.1600366113
Prior report of water clarity loss after the spiny water flea outbreak in Mendota; biological and ecosystem-service context.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesThe sampled clarity peak moved later relative to the Daphnia count peak in Mendota than in Monona in matched 1996–2018 surveys
Its clarity timing result motivated this follow-up and supplied the main coverage and lake-matching rules. We add same-day Daphnia support and relative grazer dates.