Log power did not significantly improve shrinkage-LDA AUC over linear power in eight SEEG subjects
We compared log power, linear power, amplitude, and rank-normal band-power features for offline cued key-press versus rest classification in eight SEEG subjects from OpenNeuro ds004473. A shrinkage LDA was trained on trials 1–100 and evaluated on trials 101 onward. For the primary 70–150 Hz plus 13–30 Hz feature set, log power did not significantly improve AUC over linear power (mean difference +0.0047, 6 of 8 subjects, one-sided exact sign-flip p = 0.137). For 70–150 Hz alone, log power was higher in 7 of 8 subjects (mean +0.0079, raw p = 0.023; Holm-adjusted p = 0.070). Amplitude and rank-normal features did not differ significantly from log power. Linear power was more right-skewed (median absolute skewness 1.43 versus 0.25 for log), but observed AUC changes were small: at most 0.020 for the combined high-gamma and beta features and 0.031 for high gamma alone. This offline analysis covers one dataset, one task, one session per subject, and eight subjects. No non-inferiority margin was pre-registered, so the results do not establish equivalence.
SEEG · band power · shrinkage LDA · AUC · key-press detection · log transform · rank-normal transform · OpenNeuro
References
2- usesBeta power increased later-trial SEEG key-press AUC in 6 of 8 subjects sci:sha256:b76113878b22b13b8fce6b4b57cf321bb22ce16b618b55ae02c2ef42b972f816
We used the archived ds004473 HG and beta band-power features and the numpy shrinkage LDA from this package without change.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004473.v1.0.2
The archived features used in this analysis were extracted from OpenNeuro ds004473 v1.0.2. The dataset version and feature provenance are documented in the source publication; exact-version metadata records this DOI and a CC0 license.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsIn eight SEEG subjects, 12 of 15 decoder changes reduced trial-level AUC; four were non-inferior at a 0.02 margin
Log power was not significantly better than linear power (linear: mean -0.005, not significant).
- supportsHeavy tailed SEEG band power did not improve robust shrinkage LDA movement decoding
Another feature-distribution change (winsorizing) also stayed close to log-power LDA AUC.