Mean capture mass fell in 1978–2002 but had no clear trend in 2003–2025 on two Portal control plots
We tested whether the lack of a clear energy trend reported for Portal rodents through 2002 extends to 2003–2025. We used PortalData release 6.117.0 and two plots that remained free of direct treatments. The sample contains identified seed-eating rodents, 46 eligible years in 1978–2025, and 7,155 capture records. We kept complete 49-trap censuses, preserved sampled zeros, removed exact duplicate rows, and filled 2.1% of capture masses. We compared log trends with intervals that allow temporal correlation. The 2003–2025 energy index trend was −17.5% per decade, with a 95% interval of −42.3% to +17.8%. This result establishes neither decline nor stability within 10% per decade. With mature quality-control data only, the estimate was −2.0% (−23.7% to +25.9%). Mean capture mass fell by 18.0% per decade in 1978–2002 (−23.4% to −12.2%). Its later trend was +3.3% (−4.3% to +11.5%). The slopes differ after adjustment for four tests (P = 0.00015). Between 1978–1987 and 2016–2025, mean mass fell from 50.60 g to 34.85 g. An exact decomposition assigns −16.39 g to changes in species mix and +0.65 g to changes within species. Two-year block intervals are −22.84 to −9.24 g and −0.68 to +1.54 g. The package provides source data, hashes, a duplicate audit, code, figures and sensitivity checks. This is an extension of known community patterns. Limits include one site, two adjacent plots, missing seasons, recent data quality and unknown capture probability. The energy index is based on mass; it does not measure direct energy flow or establish a cause.
community change · body mass · species composition · Portal Project · granivores · energy index · reproducibility · data audit · null result
References
7- usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.23574040
PortalData release 6.117.0 supplies the capture, species, treatment and trapping records.
- doi:10.1086/424766
[Legacy relation: reproduces] We repeat the early community comparison with two untreated plots. We extend the energy trend test through 2025.
- doi:10.1086/592402
This work explains the resource-based predictions behind the earlier comparison of counts, body mass and energy use.
- doi:10.1002/ecy.3709
This study shows that functional compensation changes through time in the Portal removal experiment. It gives related evidence and a different treatment-based question.
- usesdoi:10.1101/332783
The living data paper documents the sampling design, treatment history and data notes.
- usesdoi:10.21105/joss.01098
We checked species filters and the mass-based energy index against portalr. The analysis uses our Python code and stricter sampling filters.
- usesAdult rodents at Portal, Arizona, were not lighter in warmer years and did not lose mass in 1977–2026 in 11 species; their hindfoot length decrease is mainly measurement drift sci:sha256:02d4faafd2cb2057befdd2db284922c6f1cf828dc3bc94c9ea3f938417f2cd98
We reuse the retained source archive associated with this study. Its adult mass results give context for our separate community-level decomposition.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Adult male desert pocket mouse mass showed no clear response to the 2015 access change on 15 Portal plots in 2010–2019
This study separates community mass change from changes in species mix. We test one species.