GCMT centroid delay identified classic tsunami earthquakes but gave no clear out-of-sample tsunami forecast gain for 1,202 shallow coastal M6.5+ earthquakes (1976-2025)
Tsunami earthquakes have slow ruptures and make larger tsunamis than their magnitude predicts. We used the Global CMT centroid time delay, with the moment scaling removed (delay ~ M0^0.30), as a slowness measure. We matched 1,202 shallow (50 km or less), offshore or coastal GCMT earthquakes of Mw 6.5 or more (1976-2025) to the NCEI/WDS tsunami database. The five classic tsunami earthquakes (Nicaragua 1992, Java 1994, Peru 1996, Java 2006, Mentawai 2010) had delay residuals at the 79th to 99.5th percentiles. In the planned test, we fitted logistic models on 1976-2005 and tested them on 2006-2025. Adding the delay residual to Mw, depth, mechanism and coast distance did not reduce the log loss for tsunamis of 1 m or more: +0.06% (95% bootstrap -2.8% to +2.8%; base AUC 0.94). The reverse time split, any-tsunami and maximum-height outcomes, reverse faults only, Mw 7 or more, and the GCMT half-duration also gave no clear gain. A simulation showed only 7.4% power at the full-period effect size. In exploratory fits for Mw 7 or more, the delay coefficient was positive in both eras (all years 2.31 +/- 0.94). Without the five classic events, it fell to 1.67 +/- 0.97 (p = 0.085). The catalog delay marks rare extreme slow ruptures but carries little general tsunami-size information. Limitations: incomplete small-tsunami reports, observation-density effects on maximum height, hypocentre-time errors, and few tsunami earthquakes.
tsunami · tsunami earthquake · Global CMT · centroid time delay · rupture duration · out-of-sample test · NCEI tsunami database · earthquake source · hazard forecasting · null result
References
6- usesdoi:10.1016/0031-9201(72)90058-1
Defines tsunami earthquakes with slow ruptures; we test a catalog proxy for this slowness.
- usesdoi:10.1029/JB086iB04p02825
Centroid-moment tensor method behind the GCMT catalog.
- usesdoi:10.1016/j.pepi.2012.04.002
Global CMT project catalog that supplies the centroid delays, moments and mechanisms.
- usesdoi:10.1029/98JB02236
Energy-to-moment discriminant for tsunami earthquakes; the comparison measure that we did not compute.
- usesdoi:10.7289/V5PN93H7
NCEI/WDS Global Historical Tsunami Database supplies the tsunami outcomes.
- useshttps://www.ldeo.columbia.edu/~gcmt/projects/CMT/catalog/
GCMT NDK files for 1976-2025.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- USGS PAGER fatality probabilities for 9,130 earthquakes in 2013-2026 gave 9 times too many events with deaths, mainly because PAGER 2.x sets zero modelled deaths to 0.5
Related campaign result that uses the same NCEI hazard service for tsunami outcomes.
- usesDeep earthquakes had shorter moment-scaled centroid delays in GCMT Mw 6.5 to below 7.5 records from 1990-2020
Prior campaign use of centroid delay and its catalog limits. We use the overlapping frozen catalog for a different depth comparison, not an independent dataset.