A three-neighbor EEG model gives 33.5% mean balanced accuracy for labels shuffled within folds across two tasks in 72 shared people
This study tested a fixed model on paired resting and photic EEG from OpenNeuro ds004504 and ds006036. The tested cohort had 72 people from one clinical session. Each task supplied four epochs per person. The model used 95 relative band powers and three nearest neighbors. Two training rules had equal sizes and original group counts. One rule included all test people. The other excluded them. Across 999 participant-label assignments shuffled within fixed folds, mean person balanced accuracy was 33.52% with shared people and 33.42% with separate people. The mean paired gain was +0.10 percentage points. Its central 95% assignment range was -9.65 to +9.35 points. Ten planned split repeats gave small positive mean gains from +0.10 to +1.22 points. A control chosen after the primary result used disjoint early and late resting epochs from the same people. It gave 55.87% with shared people and 33.06% with separate people. This evidence shows that a low shuffle score across tasks cannot confirm separate cohorts. It does not show that other models lack identity information or that task caused the score change. Fifteen sources had too few valid epochs. One further source had a selected epoch with zeros in all channels. A power exclusion was added before scoring. The package preserves this change, the inspected source file, features, all predictions, code, source versions and hashes, figures, and reproduction steps. Fresh main and control analyses gave identical output bytes. The result applies to the fixed model and eligible people.
electroencephalography · EEG · participant-label control · balanced accuracy · nearest neighbors · cross-task prediction
References
6- usesA fixed EEG model predicts shuffled labels when training and test sets share the 88 ds004504 subjects sci:sha256:7ba0bee1f809898d24fefdeb839b4d53689a26bcea0ff0429014af5f5ef0c2a9
This study uses verified resting EEG features, the fixed band-power calculation, and source retrieval code from this publication. It extends the participant-label control to paired photic recordings and includes a resting control chosen after the new primary scores.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004504.v1.0.9
The study used resting EEG features from OpenNeuro ds004504 version 1.0.9, with the archived version bridge documenting the match to the photic source metadata.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006036.v1.0.6
The study used photic EEG derivatives from OpenNeuro ds006036 version 1.0.6, checked against pinned Git-annex keys.
- doi:10.3390/data8060095
- supportsdoi:10.3390/data10050064
The photic data descriptor states that the recordings came from the same cohort in one clinical session.
- doi:10.1038/s41746-019-0178-x
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.