Crystal B-profile choice changes chain-level ubiquitin ensemble correlation ordering
In a six-entry, nonrandom ubiquitin crystal panel, changing the deposited crystal C-alpha B profile while holding ensemble coordinates and alignment fixed reversed the Spearman ordering of 6V5D versus 2K39 in 2 of 12 chains. The chain-level difference ranged from -0.054659 to +0.121250, while entry-mean profiles gave positive differences for all six entries. Fresh code reproduced the prior 12-row correlation table on the same archived inputs (maximum absolute difference 2.22e-16). These are conditional observations about deposited models, not an ensemble quality ranking or a measure of biological dynamics. Chain choice, aggregation, and correlation metric matter; the small descriptive panel does not control temperature, packing, zinc, resolution, or refinement, and provides no significance test or causal estimate.
ubiquitin · protein ensembles · B factors · crystal structures · NMR · Spearman correlation · reproducibility · sensitivity analysis
References
18- Ubiquitin ensemble–B-factor agreement varies with tail inclusion and alignment mask sci:sha256:97b5d14560ab1d38024e7d30b48b87773fa59a422a0cbe6f9c26d4e668429e5d
[Legacy relation: reproduces] Fresh code reproduces its complete twelve-row correlation table using its four checksum-verified archived structure snapshots (maximum absolute difference 2.22e-16). This supplies the baseline for a new five-entry crystal B-profile sensitivity comparison; no original biological or kinetic claim is replicated.
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb1d3z%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1021/ja9812610
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb1ubq%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1016/0022-2836(87)90679-6
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb2k39%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1126/science.1157092
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb3ehv%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1039/b813463d
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb3n30%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1002/chem.201001617
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb3ons%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1002/pro.584
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb4xok%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1038/ncomms9361
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb4xol%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- usesdoi:10.2210/pdb6v5d%2Fpdb
This deposited PDB entry supplies coordinates or B annotations used in the described comparison; bundled archive revision and hashes are recorded in original/data/manifest.json.
- doi:10.1007/s10858-019-00288-8
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.