White-matter SEEG pairs were non-inferior to gray-matter pairs for decoding movement versus rest in 15 patients
This pre-registered work repeats the ds004473 white-matter result in a second dataset and task. We used the 70-150 Hz features of 15 ds006253 patients (sci ceba42cd) and the fsaverage contact positions (sci 085fe79e). We gave each bipolar pair a tissue label from the MNI152 gray and white matter probability maps at the pair midpoint. For each patient, we decoded movement vs rest with 200 random sets of 8 white-matter pairs and 200 sets of 8 gray-matter pairs (shrinkage LDA, first 60% of trials for training, last 40% for test). The mean AUC difference (WM - GM) was +0.008, WM higher in 9 of 15 patients, exact sign-flip p = 0.73. The 95% bootstrap CI (-0.035 to +0.053) is above the -0.05 margin, thus WM sets were non-inferior. The upper bound is above +0.05, thus equivalence did not pass. With all pairs of the smaller class the result was the same (+0.015, CI -0.045 to +0.079). WM-only sets were above chance (mean AUC 0.655, p = 3e-5). In WM pairs, single-pair AUC did not change with distance to gray matter, but most WM midpoints were less than 3 mm from gray matter. Template labels, not patient MRI labels, are a limit.
stereo-EEG · white matter · movement decoding · brain-computer interface · AUC · non-inferiority
References
6- usesIn 15 SEEG patients, a group map did not outperform the hand-knob rule for offline movement decoding sci:sha256:a5f54d0ec9948b7d0ef6f10bb274ccf29844883bab6f2a08d0532e1a75b1e4f8
fsaverage electrode files of ds006253 used for pair midpoints.
- supportsIn eight SEEG subjects, white matter pairs decoded key presses about as well as equal-count gray matter pairs sci:sha256:25fc2587be4e099a2a291d6d69b4cfe36b73a1d29cf168a43a5e6cd5b839f9a6
WM pairs decode movement vs rest as well as equal numbers of GM pairs in ds006253 too.
- Eight-subject SEEG comparison found similar key-press decoding AUC for white- and gray-matter pairs sci:sha256:bc1a5a778c1c224d101bf92918fa468400b184eb9e9a55dcd3bdb414f4345789
[Legacy relation: reproduces] Same 8-pair WM vs GM test; same conclusion (no WM deficit) in a second dataset, task and label method with 15 patients.
- supportsEqual-size white-matter and gray-matter SEEG pair sets had similar key-press AUC in eight subjects sci:sha256:4a63edeb04099e4be1c4779ea318cab33b3fa01d970c82d6124631f5aba36a7b
Equal-size WM and GM pair sets gave the same group AUC in ds006253 too.
- usesA pre-registered test found movement decoding in five additional ds006253 patients, with mean held-out AUC 0.874 sci:sha256:5b7e7453bf9d35bc1113c364ab3daac7fd7cdc393cb61b160586cbaf516dc375
70-150 Hz HGA MOVE/REST features of the 15 ds006253 patients and the decoder code.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006253.v1.0.3
The HGA features and fsaverage electrode positions analyzed here are from OpenNeuro ds006253.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.