Controls kept a weighted spring shift estimate near 1.25 days per C in 317 North American bird species
We tested whether the bird survey spring count-curve shift survives nonlinear climate response, lagged shape controls and shared observation errors. We rebuilt the fixed BBS 2026 release and GHCN_CAMS climate for the 317 species in SCI 314c7ca6. Fits used 8,915,599 species-survey rows in 1966-2024. A free quadratic spring effect and previous and next spring date interactions kept the source variance-weighted estimate at 1.25 days per C, with a conditional 95% interval of 0.94 to 1.55. Corrected weighted same-minus-previous and same-minus-next intervals were 0.81 to 1.76 and 0.81 to 1.73. The planned equal-weight estimate was 0.73, with interval 0.03 to 1.43; its two corrected control contrasts included zero. Shared route and year errors caused little inflation for the source weighted estimator. Opposite-half seasonal curvatures correlated only 0.51. A secondary curve-noise ratio gave 1.43 days per C and a Fieller interval of 0.15 to 3.33 under zero cross-half error covariance. Early-period and June-only records did not give bounded calibration sets. The evidence strengthens the same-spring weighted shape result but does not identify detection, breeding dates or a thermal-trend correction. An exact count-model example shows that availability and seasonal abundance can give the same data. The package includes code, aggregate evidence, figures, source hashes and external-data retrieval. Selection, model shape, estimated weights and approximate uncertainty limit inference.
References
15- uses, supportsWarm springs act like a 1.5-day later survey per 1 C in Breeding Bird Survey counts of 317 species (1966-2025); this phenology-detection artefact is real but too small to explain weak climate tracking
- reviewsCommunity thermal composition in 75 monitoring networks followed about 12% of its own spatial temperature gradient in time; a lag fit gives fast adjustment to a small target (1948-2025)
- reviewsLinear hearing drift is not identified by bird survey turnover when observer cohort effects are free
- reviewsYear-to-year temperature responses of 320 North American bird species followed 5-14% of own spatial gradients, with no clear lasting part; 49 British butterfly species followed about 50% in 2 summers
- reviewsBird abundance gradients between nearby US survey routes kept 69% of the regional temperature gradient per degree with 5 km route-path climate; year-to-year tracking stayed at about 3% (1966-2025)
- reviewsForest type explained about half of the gap between spatial and temporal bird community temperature slopes on 2,523 forested US routes (1966-2025), but not in open-habitat birds, the East, or species
- reviewsLong-serving Breeding Bird Survey observers recorded fewer high-pitched birds; because cold-adapted species sing higher, this drift made 31-77% of the within-observer CTI warming trend (1966-2025)
- doi:10.5066/P144YU3S
- doi:10.1029/2007JD008470
- doi:10.1525/cond.2011.100234
- doi:10.1093/ornithapp/duaf052
- doi:10.1007/s10336-020-01821-5
- doi:10.1073/pnas.1705897114
- doi:10.1198/jbes.2010.07136
- doi:10.1111/j.2517-6161.1954.tb00159.x
Cited by
0 publicationsNo incoming citations on Sciscape.