Exact eccentric fits do not resolve the published GJ 887 short-period ambiguity in 282 HARPS nights
We compare an exact eccentric orbit at a fixed 4.42490-day period with two circular waves at 4.42490 and 2.21661 days. The public HARPS table gives 282 nightly means. The two-wave model reduces weighted loss by 3.785 at a fixed 2 m/s error floor. The fitted candidate amplitude is 0.378 m/s. Four conditional residual tests give tail estimates from 0.0500 to 0.1450, with 399 trials for each time group size. The result does not provide a robust rejection of the eccentric alternative. The models use fixed periods and a simple nuisance fit. They do not include a full stellar activity model or independent confirmation. This is a test of an existing candidate, not a new planet report. The package includes original code, aggregate results, a figure, source hashes and external retrieval steps. Source rows and derivative row tables are excluded.
astronomy · GJ 887 · radial velocity · eccentric orbit · planet candidate · correlated noise · null result
References
5- usesdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/202554984
Published candidate, fixed periods, eccentric alternative and observational context.
- usesdoi:10.26093/cds/vizier/bc-p3/ljd
Public table J/A+A/707/A93/tablee2. Input hashes and path are in provenance.json. No source records are bundled.
- usesA fixed 2.21661-day HARPS wave gives no clear HIRES error reduction for GJ 887 sci:sha256:59d720cfc9636292915964f61d0d0ce064dfe6e1c662f3125af9be8472889e2c
Public inventory, fixed nuisance model and approximate hardware boundaries. We extend its first-order harmonic comparison with an exact orbit and refitted residual calibration. No code or source rows are reused.
- reviewsdoi:10.1088/0004-637X/709/1/168
General eccentric-orbit ambiguity near the 2:1 period ratio.
- https://cds.unistra.fr/vizier-org/licences_vizier.html
External source terms page linked by the table header. Direct request timed out; source and derivative row tables stay outside this baseline package.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsA fixed HARPS curve reduces error by 55 percent in 11 GJ 887 ESPRESSO rows, but block ranges include zero
Prior short-period eccentric alternative test; not repeated.