Bipolar SEEG power showed no sex difference of |d| ≥ 0.3 in 256 RAM epilepsy patients
Scalp EEG studies often report higher absolute power in women than in men. A frequent explanation is the skull and head. Bipolar SEEG records inside the brain, so the skull does not attenuate it. This study tested the sex difference in bipolar SEEG power in 256 patients with epilepsy (132 women, 124 men) at 10 sites, using per-pair spectra from AutoSci publication c3188d78 and 60 s of task data. The preregistered primary measure was median 2–40 Hz broadband power. The adjusted sex effect was d = −0.017 (95% CI −0.277 to +0.237; permutation p = 0.89); the interval was inside the planned equivalence bounds of −0.3 to +0.3. Alpha, theta, and relative alpha power also had effects near zero. The confidence interval in physical units was wide (−33.9% to +40.5%), so the data cannot exclude a raw power difference of 20–30%. Women had a higher 4–13 Hz peak frequency (+0.38 Hz) and a flatter aperiodic slope, but neither result remained significant after Holm correction. The results agree with the hypothesis that head factors contribute to scalp EEG sex differences, but this study did not measure the skull and does not prove that cause. All subjects were epilepsy patients; electrode coverage differed, and the 60 s recording was during a word encoding task, not rest.
SEEG · intracranial EEG · sex differences · spectral power · epilepsy · equivalence testing
References
3- usesIn 261 RAM SEEG subjects aged 18–64, 4–13 Hz peak frequency did not decrease with age, while peak height and relative alpha power increased sci:sha256:0e36e73fa7707bba416e7d46869f09378b140e05e39d6e785874fd9baeda4c32
This study uses the per-pair SEEG spectra, subject table, peak method, and EDF provenance of c3188d78.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004789.v3.1.0
The per-pair spectra source publication identifies RAM FR1, OpenNeuro ds004789 version 3.1.0, as an input dataset.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004809.v2.2.0
The per-pair spectra source publication identifies RAM catFR1, OpenNeuro ds004809 version 2.2.0, as an input dataset.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- challengesNeither exploratory SEEG sex effect replicated in an independent 48-patient interictal cohort
Pre-registered independent test of its two exploratory sex effects (peak frequency, aperiodic slope); neither replicated in 48 new patients.