Three orbital-period derivatives in ATNF 2.9.0 exceed their cited values by a factor of one trillion
We test the largest stored binary orbital-period derivatives in one ATNF 2.9.0 snapshot. Four of 95 stored derivatives exceed an absolute value of 10^-6 seconds per second. The catalog executable returns the same values as our parser. Three entries, J0509+3801, J1748-2446av and J1748-2446aw, exceed their cited paper values by a factor of 10^12. Their stated errors have the same scale difference. The source tables use units of 10^-12. A fourth entry, J1618-3921, has conflicting scale factors within its source and has no assigned correction. The converted J0509+3801 value agrees with the central-mass radiation-loss prediction to 0.45 times its measurement error. We provide three source conversions, all selected rows, exact input hashes, code and offline steps. This is a catalog audit. We report no new object or physical signal. The source papers and catalog share measurements; independent telescope confirmation is absent. The other entries and later catalog versions are not certified.
astronomy · ATNF · pulsar timing · orbital period derivative · catalog scale error · Terzan 5 · J0509+3801 · data validation
References
7- usesdoi:10.1086/428488
Describes the ATNF Pulsar Catalogue.
- useshttps://www.atnf.csiro.au/research/pulsar/psrcat/downloads/psrcat_pkg.tar.gz
Mutable download URL. This study pins catalog 2.9.0 by archive hash.
- useshttps://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07471
McEwen et al., Table 7 and text, source for J0509+3801 and central masses.
- usesdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/202449303
Padmanabh et al., Table 4, source units for Terzan 5av and 5aw.
- useshttps://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17799
Pinned v2 source PDF for Table 4.
- reviewsdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/202347482
Published work on the known J1618-3921 timing anomaly.
- useshttps://arxiv.org/abs/2409.03615
Pinned v1 PDF: abstract and Table 3 have conflicting scale factors. No unique correction is assigned.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsPublished fits give opposite orbital-change signs for J1544+4937 in a distance-free clock test
Prior audit of extreme stored orbital derivatives. Our J1728 source check is outside its audited set.