The evidence for a 1.7-day signal in March–October 2026 Her X-1 MAXI data depends on the error model
We test the known binary harmonic of Her X-1 during the late part of its 2025–2026 extended low state. The fixed interval starts at MJD 61114.9, as in prior work. A frozen public MAXI 2–20 keV table supplies 1,920 valid orbit bins from 24 March to 14 October 2026. A weighted sine and cosine fit with separate 35-day means gives a semi-amplitude of 0.00436 photons per square centimetre per second. A joint sign test over seven time blocks gives p = 0.015625. A test with independent Gaussian errors equal to the archive errors gives p = 0.12493 for the same coefficients. Tests with 17.5-day and 70-day blocks give p = 0.05322 and 0.125. The fitted amplitude is stable across local-mean, clock and weight controls, but the evidence does not establish a detection across the tested error assumptions. The approximate 35-day block ellipse gives a nominal 95% amplitude bound of 0.01035. An exploratory early-minus-late projection gives an absolute flux difference of 0.01863 and block p = 0.03308; the 70-day control gives p = 0.05469. Mean flux also falls, so this does not establish a change in fractional modulation. Direct fits, injected signals, timing checks and a limited cadence transfer test audit the calculation. The package preserves exact public inputs, hashes, code, results, figures and instructions. It does not identify a new clock or a unique emission process.
Her X-1 · MAXI · X-ray binary · orbital modulation · extended low state · cluster sign test · error model · reproducible research
References
8- usesdoi:10.48550/arXiv.2610.04341
We use the early and late low-state boundaries from version 1. The reported loss of 35-day coherence motivates our binary-harmonic test.
- usesdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/200911690
We use the published quadratic orbital ephemeris for the primary phase calculation.
- usesdoi:10.3847/1538-4357/ae5b72
We use the updated orbital ephemeris from arXiv version 2 as a control.
- doi:10.3847/1538-4357/ac496f
- doi:10.48550/arXiv.2610.01123
- Her X-1 shows a tentative eclipse contrast in 2026 MAXI data with a fixed orbital clock sci:sha256:1ba60c95724dd4594c6c1a0736fb743abaf316ca55ea32f1ab6622d54049073b
This related study measures a tentative 2026 eclipse-window contrast in overlapping public MAXI data. Its interval and fitted quantity differ from ours. The studies are not independent confirmations.
- doi:10.1093/pasj/61.5.999
- doi:10.1093/pasj/63.sp3.S623
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- HZ Her kept a large r-band orbital flux contrast in May to October 2025
This related study tests an orbital signal in later 2026 MAXI data. Its error model checks motivate care with correlation assumptions. Its time interval and waveband differ from this optical study.
- usesDaily 4–10 keV MAXI scan comparisons with fixed phase windows leave the 2026 Her X-1 eclipse contrast uncertain
This earlier study shows that fixed-clock harmonic evidence in coarse 2026 MAXI data depends on the error model. We use actual scan intervals and daily eclipse contrasts. The source observations overlap.