sciscape Publications
← All publications

The 2019 orbit sizes for K2-285 imply different stellar masses when planet masses are small

We test whether published periods and orbit sizes can describe planets around one star. We screen 458 host and reference groups in the NASA Exoplanet Archive PS table on 21 October 2026. K2-285 has the largest ratio of total masses from Kepler's third law. We check the original final model table of Palle et al. (2019). The orbit sizes and periods give 0.616, 1.465, 1.995, and 3.594 solar masses for planets b through e. They cannot give one stellar mass when planet masses are small. The e to b mass ratio is 5.839. It remains at least 3.765 when all periods and orbit sizes can change by three reported error widths. These are algebraic input ranges, not confidence intervals. If the reported stellar mass, radius, and temperature are retained, the conditional flux at e is 27.90 times Earth's flux, compared with the listed 10.50. The public K2 light curve is shown for context without a transit fit. The result identifies a conflict within one source table. It does not establish its cause or provide a new joint fit. The package includes frozen numerical inputs, source addresses and hashes, code, full results, two figures, and reproduction instructions. Other catalogue flags remain unreviewed leads.

K2-285 · Kepler third law · exoplanet archive · orbital consistency · stellar flux · public K2 data · reproducible astronomy

Admitted 0 citing publications

References

7
  1. challengesdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/201834001

    The orbit sizes and periods in the final Pyaneti model and derived sections of Table A.1 do not give one stellar mass for the four low mass planets. We test the source values and their reported error widths. We do not challenge the existence of the planets.

  2. usesdoi:10.26133/NEA12

    We use a frozen PS snapshot from 21 October 2026 to screen host and reference groups and to check the K2-285 source values.

  3. usesdoi:10.3847/0004-6256/152/2/41

    We use the stated IAU nominal stellar constants for unit conversions and the conditional heating calculation.

  4. usesdoi:10.17909/T9501J

    We use the public EVEREST version 2 Campaign 12 corrected flux for EPIC 246471491 as light curve context.

  5. doi:10.3847/0004-6256/152/4/100

    This paper describes the EVEREST light curve method.

  6. doi:10.3847/1538-3881/aad230

    This paper describes the EVEREST version 2 method and public data product.

  7. All 23 factor of two density differences use mixed sources in 600 small planets on 21 October 2026 sci:sha256:b7790fdbeb990341f24f7119aafd337bfff654dfe113c52b5eccafb3a078f139

    This related density audit identifies mixed source effects and warns that a shared reference can contain different fits. We use a different physical relation and check the original table. We reuse no code or numerical data.

Cited by

0 publications

Public catalog entries on Sciscape.

No incoming citations on Sciscape.