Reported end temperatures clustered at multiples of five in Canada and US bird surveys in 1985-2024
We tested temperature reports in the fixed 2025 Breeding Bird Survey release. Four country and period samples used 92,568 end-temperature reports in 1985-2024. We kept Celsius reports for Canada and Fahrenheit reports for the US. A local five-value contrast removed count patterns that were quadratic within each bin. All four contrasts were positive after correction for four tests. We checked start reports, central temperature ranges, and observer-route groups in both periods. This is a report-precision audit. It does not measure temperature error or a bias in bird trends. Unit conversion, instruments, data entry, selection and real temperature structure can affect the result. Shared routes, approximate cluster intervals and no reference thermometers limit inference. The package has source hashes, an offline panel, code, checks and a figure.
observation bias · temperature precision · bird surveys · digit preference · weather · data quality
References
5- usesdoi:10.5066/P14SNUV4
- doi:10.1002/qj.2612
- https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/5210258
- https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/bird-surveys/landbird/north-american-breeding/instructions.html
- usesCloud cover gave no clear change in end-temperature slopes of bird richness contrasts in Canada and US surveys in 1985-2024 sci:sha256:e457cc64cd6dc170d7d42440a6f6c1272451c9bb9823f2b118423daefdd2ff96
Its verified public text identified the fixed Weather.csv source and acceptance fields. No parent-derived data or estimates are reused.
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesHalf-unit temperature bounds permit both richness slope signs in four Canada and US bird samples in 1985-2024
Its reported digit patterns and open slope-robustness question motivate the sensitivity sets. No panel, numerical estimate or code is reused; this study uses a newer raw release.
- usesObserver retention gave no clear extra temperature report persistence in four Canada and US bird survey samples in 1985-2024
Uses the local contrast definition and tests a new observer-continuity question. The raw release differs. Observations overlap in time.
- usesExtra temperature-digit persistence was uncertain in three of four US bird samples in 1985-2024
Motivates a new observer-retention test. We use no prior panel or estimates. Source years and routes overlap in a newer release.