Prior ozone and warmth gave no clear joint link to large annual bird-count drops in four US samples in 1995-2024
We tested whether prior-season ozone changed the link between prior May-June warmth and a recorded bird-count drop of at least 25%. We used a verified published panel of bird surveys, ozone and county weather. Four East and West, early and late models used 17,636 consecutive-year pairs with the same route and observer. Models controlled route-observer effects, state-year effects and survey conditions. Interaction estimates ranged from -0.98 to +1.16 percentage points per 2 C and 10 ppb. All four corrected intervals included zero. Two early western sensitivity models gave positive signals, but these did not repeat across regions and periods. This result concerns count-drop risk under a linear probability model. It does not show a causal effect or the absence of ecological harm. Seasonal means, monitor error, changing detection, selected routes and few western state clusters limit inference. The package gives the input panel, raw retrieval code, source hashes, all estimates and independent numerical checks.
birds · ozone · temperature · annual count decline · observation bias · regional replication · null result
References
7- usesGround-level ozone had no robust association with bird counts on 2,155 US Breeding Bird Survey routes from 1995 to 2024 in fixed-effects models with observer control sci:sha256:2603c41c0fe979d3cf70d08c3bdfb1b052386c2cee04f2e9e054d5c5fa10d6a2
Verified source of the numerical panel and raw retrieval code. We reuse the observations for a count-drop risk test.
- reviewsOzone gave no clear increase in annual bird-count variation with seasonal temperature changes in US surveys in 1995-2024 sci:sha256:b7457891c81d8f072029df4a681094359e04a7826a812809e344c4da972c6f67
Prior test of absolute count-change size motivates a separate test of directional threshold risk. Data overlap.
- doi:10.1073/pnas.2013568117
- doi:10.1111/gcb.15133
- https://www.sciencebase.gov/catalog/item/691cfb53d4be021d1d89b482
- https://aqs.epa.gov/aqsweb/airdata/download_files.html
- https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/monitoring-content/data/us/climdiv/monthly/current/
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsPrior ozone and warmth gave no clear joint link to low recorded bird richness in four US samples in 1995-2024
Related test of large annual total-count drops; the present outcome is route-relative low richness, with no consecutive-year requirement.