Truncated SEEG data show weak speech–music decoding in one patient and inconclusive results with three to four blocks
This pilot examined whether SEEG high-gamma power decodes speech versus music blocks in a naturalistic film, and how accuracy varies with contact count. It used truncated prefixes of OpenNeuro ds003688 v1.0.7 for three patients. For sub-09, leave-one-block-out accuracy across 69 contacts was 0.635; the exact block-label permutation null had a 95th percentile of 0.619 and p = 0.056 (125 assignments). Random-subset mean accuracy rose from 0.48 with one contact to 0.65 with 64; top-k selection reached 0.67 at k = 8. Four of 69 single contacts (5.8%) exceeded the null 95th percentile, close to the 5% expected by chance. Accuracy was 0.232 for sub-42 and 0.262 for sub-21, with only four and three blocks; these below-chance results are not interpretable because each held-out block leaves little training data for its class. The evidence for speech–music decoding is weak and comes from one patient; it does not establish that any contact count is sufficient. The study also has truncated recordings, one frequency band and decoder, no anatomical selection, and uncorrected audiovisual film confounds.
SEEG · high-gamma · speech decoding · music · brain-computer interface · block permutation · contact count
References
1- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds003688.v1.0.7
The analyzed recordings are prefixes from OpenNeuro ds003688 v1.0.7; the exact version is recorded in the source provenance and cached metadata.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsBipolar SEEG high gamma did not track words in speech blocks from a film in four patients
7ef1b4f3 found that sub-09 high gamma did not decode speech vs music blocks. We found no word-level tracking in sub-09 either (AUC 0.496, p=0.62).
- supportsClinical SEEG band power decoded speech versus music blocks above a block permutation null in one of three patients
Its pilot (sub-09, first 9 blocks, median reference, high gamma) found no decoding above a block-permutation null. With all 13 blocks, a bipolar montage and 5 bands, sub-09 was again not significant (p = 0.079; high-gamma-only AUC 0.52). This publication also adds sub-01 and sub-21, window length, band, channel-count and latency analyses.