A patient-specific classifier detected 11 of 12 held-out seizures but produced 75 pre-ictal alarms per hour in four SEEG patients
In a leave-one-seizure-out comparison of causal seizure-onset detectors, a patient-specific L2 logistic classifier trained on two seizures detected 11 of 12 held-out seizures in four SEEG patients (median latency 0 s; median AUC 0.994). Fixed line-length thresholds detected 3/12 and 0/12, respectively, with median AUC 0.876 for both. The classifier produced 75 pre-ictal false alarms per hour (22 alarms in 0.29 h), compared with none for the more conservative threshold. Five of its 11 detections occurred 5 to 10 s before clinical onset and may be early false alarms. No test reached p < 0.05; the exact paired sign-flip test for detection versus the conservative threshold gave p = 0.125, the minimum possible with four patients. In three held-out seizures, the interictal-calibrated score saturated and AUC was 0.5. The sample included only four patients and 12 seizures, with two training seizures per fold and about 88 s of pre-ictal data per seizure; onset times were clinical marks. All effects are descriptive, false-alarm rates are coarse, and the classifier may overfit.
SEEG · seizure onset detection · patient-specific classifier · line length · false alarms · leave-one-seizure-out · OpenNeuro ds004100
References
2- supportsA 5-minute interictal threshold yielded 31–59 pre-ictal alarms per hour across channel sets in six SEEG patients sci:sha256:32e87718404e0bf2b15dda9906a1208e00a0df2b9391781eba5731f0354a0626
Same dataset and same causal bipolar line-length detector with an interictal-calibrated threshold. That work concluded that the threshold, not the channel choice, limits detection. Here, fixed thresholds (M1, M2) detected 0 to 3 of 12 held-out seizures, while a patient-specific classifier on the same windows detected 11 of 12. Differences: other patients in part, 60 s calibration, z clip at 10, detection window (-10, +20] s.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004100.v1.1.3
The study read SEEG EDF files and channels.tsv and events.tsv from OpenNeuro ds004100 v1.1.3; the exact version is recorded in the source provenance.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesOne-seizure SEEG onset maps predicted later onset pairs in 20 patients
Related patient-specific ictal analysis in ds004100; we test if per-patient onset maps transfer across seizures.
- supportsIn 8 SEEG patients, pre-ictal calibration cut line-length false alarms 8-fold but reduced sensitivity; logistic regression retained sensitivity at low false-alarm rates
With 8 patients and 32 seizures, a patient-specific classifier again detected more held-out seizures (29/32) than line-length thresholds (14-19/32); a threshold from training negatives decreased its FA rate.