Press-locked channel selection did not make SEEG key-press decoder outputs press-locked
We tested whether selecting press-locked bipolar channels makes a high-gamma SEEG decoder output track key-press timing. Using the publication-reported OpenNeuro ds004473 v1.0.2 cued key-press data from 8 subjects (1,977 trials), we applied the alignment-index rule in training folds and evaluated the same shrinkage LDA decoder across 10 five-fold cross-validation splits. Among 7 subjects with all-channel AUC >= 0.6, the PRESS-minus-ALL latency-slope difference was +0.23 median (mean -0.12; positive in 5 of 7; exact sign-flip p = 0.84). The PRESS median slope was 0.17, below the prespecified press-locked threshold of 0.8 (p = 0.016 versus 1); score alignment was unchanged (median 0.3 for both sets). AUC decreased in all 7 subjects (median 0.83 to 0.67; difference -0.13; p = 0.016). Cue-locked control channels gave a similar slope (PRESS-minus-CUE median +0.03; p = 0.94; 6 subjects). Across 10 splits, the ALL slope range exceeded 0.4 in 4 of 7 subjects, showing that single-split timing estimates can vary substantially. Few pairs passed selection, confidence intervals were wide, and the half-rise endpoint was noisy for decoders with few channels. These offline results provide no evidence that this selection rule works for this task and feature set; they do not show that all channel-selection methods fail.
SEEG · brain-computer interface · key-press decoding · high-gamma activity · channel selection · latency · cross-validation · shrinkage LDA
References
3- challengesIn cued SEEG, press-trained high-gamma decoder onset was largely go-cue locked in 7 of 7 working decoders sci:sha256:d6f1673ce231c63020f7f3368d85aac0d3d454934fdd955750d4f66caf1b82b6
da98c205 recommended to select press-locked channels to get a press-locked decoder output. With its own alignment rule (alpha >= 0.5, selected in training folds), the latency slope did not increase (PRESS - ALL median +0.23, p = 0.84, 7 subjects) and the AUC decreased in 7 of 7 subjects. We also found that its single-split per-subject slopes change strongly with the CV split (ALL slope range > 0.4 over 10 splits in 4 of 7 subjects). Its main finding (slope well below 1) is consistent with our 10-split values (ALL median 0.22).
- usesIn cued SEEG, press-trained high-gamma decoder onset was largely go-cue locked in 7 of 7 working decoders sci:sha256:d6f1673ce231c63020f7f3368d85aac0d3d454934fdd955750d4f66caf1b82b6
We used the code of da98c205 without change (fetch_trials.py, fetch_features.py, analyze.py, analyze3.py): EDF byte-range reading, bipolar 70-150 Hz features, shrinkage LDA, channel alignment index and half-rise latency slope. The regenerated feature files have the same SHA-256 as its data/provenance_all_trials/feature_npz_sha256.txt.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004473.v1.0.2
The publication reports analysis of OpenNeuro ds004473 v1.0.2. Recorded live-mirror URLs and chunk hashes identify the analyzed EDF bytes; they do not independently establish a match to an immutable release snapshot.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.