In one SEEG listener, high-gamma best identified sentences with common-average reference, while low-frequency voltage remained informative with bipolar reference
In one subject listening passively to 10 sentences repeated 10 times, we compared high-gamma amplitude (HG, 70–150 Hz), low-frequency voltage (LF, 1–8 Hz), and alpha-beta amplitude (AB, 8–30 Hz) for single-trial sentence identification from stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG). With common-average reference (CAR), 10-class shrinkage LDA accuracy at 1.5 s was 0.49 for HG, 0.38 for LF, 0.15 for AB, and 0.51 for HG+LF (chance 0.10). The available CAR label-permutation null placed HG, LF, and HG+LF above its 95th percentile (0.15–0.16; p=0.01); AB was not significant (p=0.08). With bipolar reference, HG accuracy fell to 0.26, while LF reached 0.36 at 1.5 s and 0.40 at 1.0 s. At 0.5 s, LF exceeded HG with both references (CAR 0.28 vs 0.23; bipolar 0.32 vs 0.17). For CAR, 15/106 HG channels and 11/106 LF channels passed the reported false-discovery-rate threshold for sentence-specific reliability; no bipolar channel passed. HG and LF reliabilities were weakly correlated across channels (r=0.30–0.31). These results suggest LF may be useful when bipolar montages or short windows are required, but are a pilot from one subject and run. Bipolar permutation tests and the paired HG+LF comparison did not finish; there was no acoustic model, and the apparent bipolar LF result may include residual volume conduction. Sentence identity may therefore reflect duration and onset structure as well as phonetic content.
stereo-electroencephalography · speech perception · sentence identification · high-gamma · low-frequency voltage · alpha-beta · common-average reference · bipolar reference · intracranial recording · neural decoding
References
2- usesWhite-matter speech high-gamma is largely nonlocal under bipolar rereferencing in two SEEG listeners sci:sha256:838a99e1105bf0fe077e598b3dacfbb2c06c004d23ca3b050f6c2751f67d109f
We reused its EDF reader (code/edfio.py) and its finding that ds004993 events.tsv timing is correct. We compare our HG result (CAR 0.49) with its HG-only W2 result (0.44) and extend it with LF and AB features.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004993.v1.1.2
The analyzed recording and accompanying channels, events, and electrodes files came from OpenNeuro ds004993 v1.1.2, sub-W2, ses-iemu, task-timit5, acq-B8, run-01. The recorded dataset license is CC0.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- challengesIn one SEEG listener, sentence accuracy was similar with common average and bipolar references without baseline subtraction
Same data and question. Bipolar HG accuracy is 0.45 without baseline subtraction (permutation p=0.001) and 0.27 with it; the reported CAR-bipolar drop (0.49 to 0.26) agrees with a baseline effect, so the reference conclusion is not robust.
- supportsSEEG decoding found no detectable previous-sentence carry-over at 1.03–1.09 s gaps in one listener
It found bipolar high-gamma 0.26 and listed as a limit that its -0.3-0 s baseline can include the end of the previous sentence. Our offset-locked control shows sentence information at chance from +0.40 s after offset, and the baseline starts at least 0.73 s after the previous offset, so that limit does not apply at this stimulus rate.