Under source image order, fixed tests did not confirm photo transfer within classes in MEG and fMRI from 15 adults
We tested whether detailed visual relations remain stable when both the photograph and the person change. Public MEG and fMRI targets came from the same 15 adults in separate sessions. Two sets of 78 pictures had matched verbal descriptions. We used the intended source image order. Within each of five classes, we removed additive image effects and averaged normalized maps from five reference people. We scored the other photo set in both directions. Anonymous rows did not establish person links. We therefore bounded all possible groups of ten target people outside each reference. Late MEG mean ranges were 0.02268 to 0.05892 and -0.00770 to 0.04810. IT fMRI ranges were -0.01813 to 0.04394 and -0.03296 to 0.01638. All four outer 95% mean interval ranges crossed zero. The shared transfer rule and the late-stage advantage rule both failed; their Holm values were 1.0. One MEG image-label test gave p=0.0167 but did not pass its person rule. A same-photo check found weak detailed agreement in these fMRI targets. Thus, failure does not establish absent invariant neural information. This new endpoint extends an earlier failed paired-photo test. It is not independent acquisition confirmation. The package gives code, exact source records, all scores and label draws, figures, audits, and repeat steps. Source arrays remain external under their own rights. Source image order, fixed references, limited target quality, visual confounds, and measurement differences limit scope. No positive cross-modal neural generalization or causal claim is made.
MEG · fMRI · human vision · image classes · photograph transfer · representational geometry · person dependence · negative result · reproducibility
References
8- usesdoi:10.1038/nn.3635
Source of the 92-image method-check experiment.
- supportsdoi:10.1093/cercor/bhw135
Prior MEG-fMRI representational fusion method and source experiment description.
- usesdoi:10.3390/vision3010008
Human twin-photograph source experiment; its ordered-description design defines tested alignment.
- usesdoi:10.48550/arXiv.1905.05675
Algonauts 2019 public compact MEG and fMRI target release.
- usesImage offsets explained 72–89% of early MEG–fMRI covariance in four image sets, but did not pass fixed fMRI tests sci:sha256:3a94f11b6b838159ba3d000970b36a269fd7c82211486399a060c21a15a890d1
Its image-effect audit motivates separate within-class endpoint controls.
- usesFive classes supplied 98% of observed cross-photo covariance in late MEG and IT fMRI; detailed transfer was not confirmed in one cohort sci:sha256:64cd1693ab43d8bdfa27013a3ebd780950951e536cbabddc31686745f9c43eeb
We extend its failed paired-person cross-photo test with category-balanced group references and bounds over unknown person links. No source code was copied.
- usesIn 15 adults, 24 reference images supported within-class matching of 68 other images between MEG and fMRI sci:sha256:f18d20c48e7a6f3575db4f51a9119f388f153889882efb2622461b05ac888089
Its checked archive records, class counts, and conservative treatment of anonymous person links informed retrieval and design. New code implements the present endpoint.
- supportsdoi:10.7554/eLife.82566
Explains why person inference must be distinguished from inference over new stimuli.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesA fixed test did not confirm image isolation across photographs in MEG and fMRI from 15 adults
Its missing-person-link audit motivates the new all-bijection count test. We wrote new code.