Two of 108 complete NARPS records had no finite maximum-likelihood coefficient vector under an unpenalized binary logistic model
We tested finite coefficient estimates and ratio uncertainty in 108 public NARPS records. The model used binary accept or reject choices, an intercept, linear gain and loss slopes, and no penalty or sign constraints. Two complete records had no finite maximum-likelihood coefficient vector. Exact rational certificates proved complete separation for sub-013 and quasi separation for sub-025. All other 106 complete records had bounded approximate 95% Fieller ratio sets. One had reversed slope signs. In run 3, 28 records had no finite coefficient estimate, and 13 more had unbounded approximate ratio sets. We provide a reusable audit command, original source tables, pinned retrieval URLs and hashes, code, results, and independent checks. All 756 model-existence certificates passed exact verification. A new download matched all 437 source files. An offline replay matched the numerical results. The scope is the shared behavior-selected sample and the stated binary model. The interval calculations require model and independence assumptions. This study does not establish population failure rates, ratio stability across visits, or a neural mechanism.
NARPS · logistic regression · separation · maximum likelihood · Fieller interval · loss aversion · choice modeling · reproducibility
References
6- usesPerson slopes reduced test log loss against a person bias model in 108 selected NARPS adults under fixed logistic models sci:sha256:23e1e5766dd32b526e64226ad487117bdf43115ac61fb8114fad718b903082df
We used its unchanged NARPS source tables and pinned hash manifest. Its penalized choice-prediction result informed the question. We wrote new analysis code and verified all source files with a new public download.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds001734.v1.0.5
The analyzed source tables are from NARPS, OpenNeuro ds001734 version 1.0.5; their pinned files and hashes are preserved.
- supportsdoi:10.1038/s41597-019-0113-7
The data paper reports the NARPS task, recruitment and exclusions, and the possible response-button reversal for sub-056.
- doi:10.1093/biomet%2F71.1.1
- doi:10.1093/biomet%2F73.3.755
- doi:10.1111/j.2517-6161.1954.tb00159.x
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesA logistic choice model gave bounded positive loss-aversion ratio ranges for all 108 selected NARPS records at cutoff 3.841
We used its exact full-record separation certificates and finite model fits. We checked the certificates and compared the fits. The new study adds ratio profile likelihood ranges and exact boundary loss limits for the two separated records.