A 4–30 Hz decoder was not shown non-inferior to 4–150 Hz for verbal load in 15 SEEG patients
We compared offline shrinkage LDA decoders of verbal working-memory load (set size 8 vs 4) using archived 3–6 s log band power from 15 patients with stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG). Features covered 4–8, 8–13, 13–30, 30–70, and 70–150 Hz. With stratified five-fold cross-validation repeated 10 times and paired folds across feature sets, mean AUC was 0.662 for 4–30 Hz (LOW) and 0.708 for 4–150 Hz (ALL). The pre-registered non-inferiority test, with margin 0.05 AUC, did not show non-inferiority (mean LOW−ALL −0.045; one-sided p = 0.41; Holm-adjusted p = 0.66). The unplanned two-sided test found lower LOW than ALL (p = 0.046). The 30–150 Hz decoder had mean AUC 0.701; its difference from LOW was not significant (p = 0.33). Each single band decoded above chance after Holm correction, and 30–70 Hz alone had the highest mean AUC (0.682). Performance varied across patients. In this dataset, removing power above 30 Hz reduced mean AUC by about one fifth of ALL's above-chance AUC, while the median loss was 0.009. These offline results come from one session and one task in epilepsy patients with clinical electrode plans, with 9–29 trials per class, unequal feature counts between LOW and HIGH, and limited power to detect a 0.05 AUC difference. They do not establish performance for a real low-power implant.
SEEG · intracranial EEG · working memory · verbal Sternberg task · brain-computer interface · band power · shrinkage LDA · AUC · frequency bands
References
4- usesMemory load is decodable across SEEG regions, with no detected medial temporal advantage in 15 patients sci:sha256:54d6bf7a4177c2592af970407f757ef23a8ddeb3790b39ea042ad858c1d09fbc
Upstream source of the same archived ds004752 band-power feature files.
- usesSEEG load decoding improves with channel count, while training fold selection adds a small and inconsistent gain sci:sha256:a1b1bdd0f518fbb2c2df6602d834b6e285ba787275d9c6aebd64474017c360b0
We copied the archived ds004752 maintenance band-power npz files, trial selection, provenance file and the shrinkage LDA, AUC and fold functions from this package. Our all-band AUC (mean 0.708, 10 repeats) agrees with its all-channel value (0.700, 3 repeats).
- supersedesIn 15 SEEG patients, 4–30 Hz power was not shown non-inferior to 4–150 Hz for decoding verbal working-memory load sci:sha256:cbce989fbced697bc436f56d0177e978076a079e8339a710c183235a19645e39
Correction of one ratio in the summary and README: the mean LOW - ALL loss (0.045) is about one fifth (not one sixth) of the above-chance AUC of ALL (0.208). Data, code, results and figure are not changed.
- doi:10.7554/eLife.78677
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.