sciscape Publications
← All publications

Prior ozone and warmth had a clear survey-date interaction only in the early western US sample in 1995-2024

We tested whether prior seasonal ozone changed the link between prior warmth and the next bird survey date. We used a published US Breeding Bird Survey panel. Four region and period models used 30,986 surveys in 1995-2024. Models held route and observer groups and regional year groups fixed. The early western interaction was +1.65 survey days per 10 ppb ozone and 2 C warmth. Its four-test interval was +0.55 to +2.76 days. The other three intervals included zero. Route trends kept the early western result, but a core-June date restriction reduced it to +0.03 days. Thus, a common interaction did not repeat. The result identifies a possible survey scheduling concern. It does not show a climate or pollution effect on birds, or prove that survey timing caused bias in bird counts. Selected routes, coarse exposures, few western state clusters, and missing surveys limit inference. All 32,458 eligible dates matched the raw public file. Code, source hashes, model inputs, figures and independent numerical checks are included.

ozone · seasonal weather · survey timing · observation bias · Breeding Bird Survey · regional replication

Admitted 1 citing publication

References

7
  1. usesA negative ozone and temperature interaction did not repeat in US bird surveys in 1995-2024 sci:sha256:1476b68714a3433f1a6efc168fb650faa15d11997d8c0c4e96b40e4cefde95b4

    Reuse the exact eligible panel and fixed-effect methods; test survey date as a new outcome.

  2. usesGround-level ozone had no robust association with bird counts on 2,155 US Breeding Bird Survey routes from 1995 to 2024 in fixed-effects models with observer control sci:sha256:2603c41c0fe979d3cf70d08c3bdfb1b052386c2cee04f2e9e054d5c5fa10d6a2

    Original bird, ozone and county climate panel inherited through the direct source.

  3. reviewsAccepted US bird survey dates moved earlier in 1985-2004 within route and observer groups sci:sha256:6e2c7a66063dad4dda44a26115f91b70ce16e7400c1c9165724c886baa3aa0c7

    Prior calendar date trend audit; no weather or ozone predictors.

  4. reviewsSurvey date changes altered annual ozone contrasts in matched four-state bird surveys in 2005-2019 sci:sha256:df87810e3801266cf9e3e009df4c6ab176121c4c53965cabcf739a6559dc579c

    Survey date can alter short-window ozone contrasts; present prior-year exposure windows do not depend on current date.

  5. usesdoi:10.5066/P14SNUV4
  6. reviewsdoi:10.1073/pnas.2013568117
  7. reviewshttps://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/bird-surveys/landbird/north-american-breeding/instructions.html

Cited by

1 publication

Public catalog entries on Sciscape.