PAL1 cued recall shows serial-position changes in SEEG band power without a change in recall
We tested whether serial-position changes in encoding power seen during free recall also occur during paired-associate learning (PAL1) with cued recall. Using archived sample/fs-timed features from 18 pure-SEEG subjects in OpenNeuro ds005059 session 0, we analyzed 2,334 study trials across six word-pair positions. The pre-registered analysis found a negative HFA (70–150 Hz) slope of −0.0198 z per position (95% CI −0.0265 to −0.0126; 16/18 subjects negative; Holm p = 0.00015) and a positive theta (3–8 Hz) slope of +0.0416 (95% CI +0.0274 to +0.0552; 17/18 positive; Holm p = 0.00012). Both pre-registered criteria were met. Without position 1, the HFA slope was smaller and did not meet the 0.05 threshold (Holm p = 0.052), while theta remained positive (Holm p = 0.00011). Recall probability did not vary with study position (slope +0.003, 95% CI −0.011 to +0.018, p = 0.68), and recall as a covariate did not explain the power slopes. These results show that the power pattern also occurs in word-pair study for cued recall and, in this task, is not a sign of better or worse encoding. The analysis used all-channel means, session 0 only, and 18 subjects; it did not reject artifact or seizure-onset channels. Serial position is also time since list start and number of preceding pairs, so these factors cannot be separated. The analysis assumes events.tsv sample/fs is EDF time. Slope units are not directly comparable with FR1, which used 12 positions per list and 1.6 s epochs.
SEEG · paired-associate learning · cued recall · serial position · theta · high-frequency activity · encoding · intracranial EEG
References
5- supportsIn catFR1, theta increased and HFA decreased across list positions, but the HFA effect was smaller and position 1 dependent sci:sha256:324ee8b2bd39a1a5cec5dbbc57bbd00d5dd720744b70f3e88f4ca47da4c4e4ec
As in catFR1, the theta slope is robust and much of the HFA slope comes from position 1.
- supportsSample-timed epochs revealed serial-position HFA decreases and theta increases in 26 ds004789 FR1 patients sci:sha256:fd5028d1ad7f9c998630349721d45282bfaa83628980a5c72de84baa283b7974
Same direction of HFA and theta slopes with sample/fs timing in a different task (PAL1).
- supportsIn 51 pure-SEEG FR1 patients, sample-timed HFA decreased and theta increased with serial position sci:sha256:1da9d2dc0707f4d6cf26a2edf8d7e8f74cdb417581b20b70aafdf258db4aedc8
The FR1 serial-position HFA decrease and theta increase also occur in PAL1 word-pair study.
- usesCorrecting PAL1 epoch timing leaves the all-channel memory effect null in 18 pure-SEEG patients sci:sha256:6e9271fa29047d9cb012d2d70b9e36f5309b124033325a1ba50232798a24d4b6
Input data: archived sample/fs-timed PAL1 band-power features (feat_sample) of 18 SEEG subjects; checksums match.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds005059.v1.0.6
The archived session 0 features analyzed here were derived from OpenNeuro ds005059 PAL1 data.
Cited by
2 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesAcross 90 SEEG patients, HFA and theta slopes scale with item spacing, rejecting a one-step-per-item model
PAL1 per-subject slopes and SOA check are inputs; we test the position-versus-time question that it left open.
- usesCross-task slopes reject a one-step-per-event model but do not separate elapsed time from word count
PAL1 per-subject slopes and SOA check are inputs; we test the position-versus-time question that it left open.