A fixed test did not confirm larger visual responses from half the exposure in five ECoG patients and six fMRI adults
We tested whether two short image pulses give a larger visual response than one continuous pulse with twice the image-on time. Separate public studies supplied ECoG broadband power and fMRI response estimates. The fixed comparison was two 133 ms pulses with a 533 ms gap versus one 533 ms pulse. Three ECoG patients supplied development. Tests used five other patients and six fMRI adults. Only one of five test patients had a positive contrast. The mean scaled difference was -0.198, with a 95% person bootstrap interval of -0.566 to +0.177. Two fMRI people had records in both source experiments, but their identity links were missing. Across all 72 links, the mean was -0.196 to -0.022 and the outer interval was -0.424 to +0.185. The shared one-sided sign p value was 0.96875. The primary claim failed. A planned descriptive check showed recovery at fixed exposure in both measurements. It does not confirm a benefit from half the exposure. Controls for baselines, response windows, spatial weights and image types remain. This is a new endpoint in reused cohorts, not a new acquisition. Finite electrical response tails, source selection, vascular readout and different stimuli limit scope. No new positive cross-modal effect or causal mechanism is claimed. The package gives a direct response-order benchmark, source code, permitted compact inputs, exact source records, all results, figures and repeat steps.
visual cortex · ECoG · fMRI · temporal summation · adaptation · response order · negative result · subject dependence
References
7- usesFixed recovery tests did not show a shared model violation in eight ECoG patients and six fMRI adults sci:sha256:a897f45ddd7b7f39f0ff91676d8367575836148c09a055ef11f9bd6f4a39f49e
We reuse its compact source trial scalars and source-style cleaning code, with attribution and independent source checks.
- usesA temporal interaction test did not show a shared violation in eight ECoG patients and six fMRI adults sci:sha256:7c356923470735652f38a6554d2f9153b5c41a85fc1dd2902d5bb9a18733b551
We obtained the verified source benchmark from its package and build on its baseline and repeated-person controls. Our response-order contrast and local development split differ.
- usesLocal mean response scaling changed temporal effect signs in two human visual cortex datasets sci:sha256:7c77855b2b64ebf6c31bf1eaa56d9d05e59214add2ca7adb929b0086943c901a
The inherited compact benchmark uses its MIT MATLAB table reader and contact reference. We retain the notice and source records.
- usesdoi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1812-21.2022
Original ECoG experiment and source processing.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004194.v3.0.0
Pinned CC0 Visual ECoG dataset version 3.0.0.
- usesdoi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1724-17.2017
Original fMRI experiment; response file OSF wn2q9 version 1, project v843t, CC BY 4.0.
- doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1007484
Prior delayed gain-control account of temporal compression and adaptation.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.