Hippocampal upper spectral quantiles showed no clear shared increase in 30 SEEG patients and ten fMRI participants at fixed bands
We tested a proposed shared regional frequency order in public human SEEG and fMRI data from separate studies. The outcome was the within-person hippocampus-minus-cortex log2 contrast in f90, the frequency below which 90% of band power occurs. A local plan fixed the outcome before the new results were calculated. Bands were 1–45 Hz in RAM SEEG and 0.01–0.08 Hz in processed PAFIN movie fMRI. A deterministic split kept 30 SEEG people for discovery and 30 for confirmation. The fMRI test used ten other people, with two movies averaged within each person. In confirmation SEEG, mean D90 was -0.0018 (95% person bootstrap interval -0.1764 to +0.1692; Holm p=0.9840). In fMRI it was +0.0182 (-0.0277 to +0.0604; Holm p=0.8789). The fixed shared-positive rule failed. Joint bands over 19 quantiles retained the known opposite middle-spectrum signs. A post-primary direct amygdala-versus-hippocampus check was also uncertain in both modalities. No new positive biological effect shared by the modalities was established. Different cohorts, tasks, frequency bands, clinical sampling, hemodynamics and regional noise limit interpretation. The package preserves the plans, complete processed inputs, source records, code, all results and figures. Independent arithmetic checks, eight fresh source matches and a full analysis repeat passed. The result limits a proposed shared order; it does not establish equal spectra or causality.
SEEG · fMRI · hippocampus · spectral quantiles · negative result · cross-modal transfer · subject-level inference
References
10- usesHippocampal median frequency contrasts had opposite signs in RAM SEEG and PAFIN fMRI with fixed frequency bands sci:sha256:f692011e23cc890321c9ad5f6be9aae3ded572962cdd07559da85d1e24212fe3
We reuse its verified spectra, labels and fMRI time series, and test whether its opposite median-frequency signs can coexist with a shared upper-tail order.
- usesIn 261 RAM SEEG subjects aged 18–64, 4–13 Hz peak frequency did not decrease with age, while peak height and relative alpha power increased sci:sha256:0e36e73fa7707bba416e7d46869f09378b140e05e39d6e785874fd9baeda4c32
Original curation of the 0.5-Hz RAM SEEG spectra, reused through SCI 00ea1714.
- usesSEEG knee timescales follow a limbic-to-neocortical axis, not a neocortical hierarchy sci:sha256:23553ec6d4bacb9bd5d4044553a75899ac170080f3e19ec2e574953b5c527d1e
Original archived RAM electrode labels, reused through SCI 00ea1714.
- usesThe true pairing had the largest cortical connectivity score across two movies in ten ds006192 participants after movie mean removal sci:sha256:d37b2419915defe483b7634a2855ce4503d3e0c5f5f7c8c95a84c3ca17f52e5e
Original PAFIN derivative time-series archive and source provenance, reused through SCI 00ea1714.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004789.v3.1.0
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004809.v2.2.0
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006192.v1.0.0
- doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1941-22.2023
- doi:10.7554/eLife.61277
- doi:10.1073/pnas.2003383117
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supersedesHippocampal upper spectral quantiles showed no clear shared increase in 30 SEEG patients and ten fMRI participants at fixed bands
Corrects the SCI source web links in the main text. Scientific inputs, code, figures, and numerical results are retained.