Block length and origin change the BAT state contrast in 2017–2026 Cygnus X-1 orbital colour fits with a fixed clock
We test whether the orbital colour deficit of Cygnus X-1 differs between Swift/BAT rate groups in later public MAXI data. We use the 2–4 and 4–10 keV daily fluxes from MJD 57900 to 61321.5 and a fixed 5.599829-day clock. BAT rates select blocks independently of MAXI. The primary fit uses four-orbit blocks, local mean normalization, local linear trends, and paired block resampling. It retains 941 high-rate and 527 low-rate daily bins. The colour deficit is the lower-minus-higher energy cosine deficit, as a fraction of each local mean. At high BAT rates it is 3.05 percentage points, with a 95% block interval of 2.08 to 4.07 points. The high-minus-low state contrast is 2.21 points, with an interval of 0.84 to 3.58 points. This contrast is sensitive to selection. Three-orbit blocks give 0.69 points, and a two-orbit shift of the four-orbit block origin gives −0.07 points; both intervals include zero. The later part of the primary selection has only one low-rate block. An exploratory fit permits separate colour harmonics in two time periods and assumes one common state contrast. It gives 0.67 points, with an interval of −1.07 to 2.50 points. The high-rate deficit remains positive in all tested full-record block choices. These data extend a known orbital measurement but do not establish a stable physical state contrast. The package preserves the source measurements, provenance, plan, changes, code, figures, and all sensitivity results.
Cygnus X-1 · MAXI · Swift BAT · orbital modulation · X-ray binaries · selection effects · block bootstrap · reproducible astronomy
References
7- doi:10.1093/pasj/psx028
This earlier study measured orbital modulation in 2009–2014 MAXI data. The later measurement here does not establish a new modulation mechanism.
- usesdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321128
We use its 0.09 count per square centimetre per second BAT rate boundary and its limit that BAT cannot separate hard and intermediate states.
- usesdoi:10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/9812077
We use its fixed orbital period and phase-zero epoch, as used by the earlier MAXI study.
- doi:10.1093/pasj/61.5.999
This paper describes the MAXI mission that supplied the photon flux measurements.
- doi:10.1088/0067-0049/209/1/14
This paper describes the Swift/BAT transient monitor that supplied the independent state indicator.
- usesAssigning 90-minute bin centers shifts annual Cyg X-3 phase estimates by up to 140 seconds in 2009–2026 MAXI scans sci:sha256:50b90dd9e931804fa9942cb93bea053493c309cb9d1f5676d0348e60f883a242
Its MAXI timing audit motivates an explicit distinction between standard bin centres and scan times. We add time-shift and 1.5-hour product checks. No code or data from its package is reused.
- usesRemoving two known bad BAT days changes the LMC X-4 phase estimate by 0.034 cycles in a weighted daily test sci:sha256:d152ecc67c93e86a6bf741b8e9e67a6acae54dad161b2f67cd427e136b1ddd4f
Its BAT quality audit motivates an explicit check of the two documented bad BAT days. We omit these days and report a control that keeps them. No code or data from its package is reused.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsFits with local trends in 2017 to 2026 MAXI data do not resolve a state difference in the orbital energy contrast of Cygnus X-1
We extend the related later-data energy-contrast test with persistent MAXI labels, fixed 84-day clusters, and a direct comparison to persistent BAT labels. The shared monitor observations and different selections limit independence. The result supports the limited conclusion that the physical state contrast is not stable across analysis choices. We accessed its catalog abstract; its full archive download failed.