Hippocampal ripple rate before free recall was higher but not significant in 15 patients
This independent test asked whether hippocampal ripple rate rises in the 600 ms before correct free recall. A pre-specified, NumPy-only detector was applied to OpenNeuro ds004789 session ses-0, read through unversioned S3 URLs. Eighteen subjects were fetched; 15 met the threshold of at least 10 clean correct recalls, contributing 119 hippocampal bipolar pairs. The primary per-subject pre-recall minus baseline rate was +0.040 events/s/pair (95% CI -0.003 to +0.082; 10/15 subjects above zero; two-sided sign-flip p = 0.097). The mean log ratio was +0.111 (95% CI -0.011 to +0.229; p = 0.10). The rate after vocal onset was lower than baseline (p = 0.026). The pre-recall effect was absent with a stricter 4 SD peak threshold (p = 0.76). Correct-recall pre-rate exceeded intrusion pre-rate with the 3 SD detector (p = 0.024), but not the 4 SD detector (p = 0.95). The result is weak, non-significant evidence in the predicted direction, not a replication at alpha = 0.05. The small sample, one 45-minute run, lack of control regions, possible speech-muscle artifact, unvalidated detector, sensitivity to threshold, and unmatched baseline timing limit interpretation. Raw signals are not included; provenance records give source URLs and hashes for the sampled byte ranges and companion files.
hippocampus · free recall · electrophysiology · ripple rate · stereo-EEG · memory · OpenNeuro
References
1- usesHippocampal theta power was lower for recalled words in 16 SEEG patients sci:sha256:46adf8ed818b937d1f9c4c8ee5798e692c840c852bfae61246d0e121f9b30aa7
Eligible subject list (meta/eligible_subjects.txt), hippocampal label rule and byte-range EDF reader code from fetch.py were reused.
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsHippocampal 80–120 Hz events rose before recall in 46 subjects, but the increase versus silent periods depended on detector threshold
Same pattern in 46 instead of 15 subjects: about 12-13% more events before recall with a 3-SD peak detector, peak at -0.75 to -0.25 s, and no effect with a 4-SD peak detector.
- supportsHippocampal ripple rates did not rise before vocal recall in 45 SEEG patients
Same dataset and question. Our pre-specified analysis of 45 subjects agrees with its null pre-recall result (our p = 0.36). It also confirms its lower ripple rate after vocal onset: in our data, [0, 1) s minus control = -0.033 events/s/pair, Holm p = 0.009. The 150-200 Hz band did not show this decrease (p = 0.79).
- usesArchived pipelines agree on subject-level ripple effects, but show no pre-recall increase in ds004789
Input F: per-subject ripple rates for correct recalls, reproduced exactly.