Current and prior summer rain slopes gave no repeated nonzero sum for nine British butterflies in 1981-2024
We tested whether summer rain had a link to annual butterfly index change beyond a stable current-weather count offset. A stable additive rain offset gives equal and opposite current and prior rain slopes. Their sum is zero. We fit this contrast to a fixed mean log10 index for nine species in England, Scotland and Wales in 1981-2024. Models controlled current and prior summer temperature, time and change in site count. All three full-period adjusted intervals included zero. In six separate country and period models, late Scotland and Wales sums were +0.138 and +0.102 log10 units per 100 mm in both summers. Their HAC intervals were above zero after six-test correction. Earlier results did not repeat. A post-fit block wild bootstrap gave corrected p-values of 0.342-0.601 and 0.079-0.119. Wider seasonal windows also gave intervals that included zero. Thus a repeated nonzero sum was not established. The contrast cannot identify biology or detection. Shared country weather, short samples, high leverage, selected species, coarse weather and missing source-index uncertainty limit inference. We do not test pollution, daily extremes or a causal climate-change effect. The package includes the method, frozen inputs, source hashes, code, all estimates, figures and offline checks.
butterflies · rainfall · observation bias · abundance index · lagged weather · regional comparison · uncertainty · UKBMS
References
8- usesEstimates for prior warm, dry summers changed sign between two abundance measures for nine butterflies in Britain in 1980-2024 sci:sha256:e2f2fce4a97d3f2fb9cb7b3a4d09597042952c93f8b42cd67bd145eeb704d3de
Its level-versus-change audit motivates the zero-sum offset restriction. We rebuild from the same public snapshots and use the same nine species; these are not independent data.
- reviewsWeather square terms changed interaction signs in two of three models of nine British butterfly species in 1981-2024 sci:sha256:4a72551f55388d87b90d2f9e5fa1e35f7f47bd534d3ebbf8140a232ae4afd95a
Prior model-shape and uncertainty audit in the same species and source snapshots. We test a different contrast.
- usesPrior summer rain had no clear common link to relative Ringlet growth in England and Wales in 1984-2024 sci:sha256:ff4e66e4fd057450a4ab2f63761a779c802509d13e9c3e3791ebb13ac390cfdf
Its shared source-rounding audit motivates our analogous bound for a different contrast. Its Ringlet-versus-Meadow Brown outcome differs.
- usesdoi:10.5285/a70d8b0b-0ef5-484e-8195-42bcfd818229
- usesdoi:10.1111/biom.12506
- reviewsdoi:10.1111/j.1365-2656.2001.00480.x
- useshttps://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/climate/maps-and-data/uk-and-regional-series
- useshttps://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/climate/maps-and-data/data/haduk-grid/methods
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsPrior summer heat peaks gave no clear common link to next-year butterfly indices in England, Scotland and Wales in 1981-2024
Prior observation-offset restriction for rain motivates a model review. We do not apply its zero-sum restriction to a free lag-index model.
- usesPrior summer rain gave no clear nitrogen contrast in four British butterfly samples in 1987-2012
We recover three frozen raw Met Office country rainfall files from the verified bundle. We do not use its collated butterfly index.
- reviewsPrior June-versus-August rain slopes did not give a clear repeated relative Ringlet index response in England and Wales in 1984-2024
- usesSummer weather adjustment reduced fitted butterfly synchrony but gave mixed held-out results in Britain in 1981-2024
Reuse seven unmodified source inputs and their provenance from the completely verified bundle. Independently rebuild species data and weather for a new held-out synchrony test.