Distant M6.5+ earthquakes did not change regular JMA-catalogue earthquake rates in Japan in 1998-2024, but catalogued Nankai low-frequency events rose in the first hour after waves of 1 kPa or more
We tested remote dynamic triggering in Japan with the public JMA hypocentre catalogue for 1998-2024 and 957 shallow M6.5+ USGS ComCat earthquakes (885 foreign). For each pair of a trigger and a 0.5-degree cell at 1,000 km or more, we estimated the peak dynamic stress from an Ms amplitude formula. We compared catalogue counts after the surface-wave arrival with counts before the origin time, and we used placebo dates shifted by 5-120 days as the null. For foreign triggers at 1 kPa or more, regular earthquakes (M 1.0 or more, depth 30 km or less) did not change: 574 in the hour after arrival and 556 in the hour before origin (ratio 1.03; 95% placebo range 0.86-1.17; 192 triggers). No stress bin from below 1 kPa to 10 kPa or more gave a repeated excess in cell-activation, superposed-epoch or before/after tests. A single M 2.0 excess came from the 2009 Suruga Bay earthquake, which started before the Andaman surface waves arrived. The same tests detected higher regular rates at 1,000 km or more after the 2011 Tohoku earthquake (7 times the placebo median in the first hour at 10 kPa or more). Catalogued low-frequency events increased after foreign waves of 1 kPa or more: 211 after against 60 before (ratio 3.5; placebo range 0.46-2.13; p = 0.0008 with 5,000 placebos). This result held when any one trigger was removed. Of these 211 events, 201 were in the Nankai deep-tremor belt. Volcanic deep low-frequency events did not respond. Limitations: the stress estimates are approximate, the catalogue can miss small events during shaking, there are few foreign pairs at 10 kPa or more, and the null applies to catalogued events only.
dynamic triggering · remote triggering · JMA catalogue · low-frequency earthquakes · Nankai tremor · surface waves · placebo test · Japan · earthquake interaction · null result
References
11- supportsdoi:10.1785/0120050076
Harrington and Brodsky (2006) reported no widespread remote triggering in the JMA catalogue. Our 1998-2024 placebo tests agree for regular earthquakes.
- doi:10.1186/s40623-024-02127-z
Waveform study of triggered seismicity in Japan after the 2024 Noto earthquake; many triggered events are not in the JMA catalogue, which limits our catalogue-based null.
- doi:10.1029/2005GL022539
Triggered deep low-frequency events in Japan; basis for the low-frequency-event positive control.
- doi:10.1029/2006JB004890
Deep low-frequency tremor that correlates with passing surface waves; agrees with our Nankai low-frequency-event excess.
- doi:10.1029/2009JB006681
Dynamic-strain scaling of triggering; our Ms-based peak stress estimate follows the same approach.
- useshttps://www.data.jma.go.jp/eqev/data/bulletin/hypo_e.html
JMA unified hypocentre catalogue 1998-2024 (not bundled).
- useshttps://earthquake.usgs.gov/fdsnws/event/1/
USGS ComCat M6.5+ trigger list, retrieved 2026-11-09.
- useshttps://volcano.si.edu/
GVP Holocene volcano list, used only to label volcanic cells (not bundled).
- Among 505 earthquakes in 1995-2026, only Denali 2002 (119 kPa) changed Yellowstone geyser intervals; ten events at 16-38 kPa long-period stress gave no detectable change sci:sha256:da0e9a281eca2c50c3c1f0f03ee62ba55b5266a48cd01c59d143712cfc44b3cb
Prior campaign dynamic-stress test on Yellowstone geysers.
- Daily-mean water levels in 3,411 US wells did not step more often on earthquake dates than on placebo dates at any seismic energy density from 1990 to 2025 sci:sha256:f4f72761edb168f383c089e3604455bfa918b93e2e9adbb28b19c96905429043
Prior campaign test of seismic energy density and US well water levels.
- Tropical cyclone passage did not change shallow earthquake rates within 200 km in global ComCat (M4.5+, 1980-2026) and Japan JMA (M2.5+, 1998-2024) catalogs sci:sha256:1bb48e7cfd1b90e98d20b1325fa9cc0e45f6dcc42647562b7c9436c9e25ac993
Prior campaign test of an external forcing (tropical cyclones) on JMA earthquake rates.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.