Treated channels were more abnormal, but this did not distinguish seizure outcome in 43 SEEG patients
We tested whether interictal SEEG abnormality was more concentrated in treated tissue among seizure-free patients than among patients who were not seizure-free. Using archived per-channel features from the first 120 seconds of one interictal clip per patient and outcome labels from HUP (OpenNeuro ds004100) and ds003876, we included 43 patients from four centers (24 seizure-free, 19 not seizure-free). The composite D_RS statistic was the Mann–Whitney AUC comparing treated with spared channels. Treated channels were more abnormal in most patients (mean D_RS 0.635; 32/43 above 0.5; sign-flip p = 9×10⁻⁵). The primary outcome comparison did not support the hypothesis: mean D_RS was 0.598 in seizure-free and 0.681 in not-seizure-free patients (difference −0.084, 95% CI −0.194 to 0.023; stratified permutation p = 0.156; outcome AUC 0.39, 95% CI 0.23 to 0.56). Each cohort and each single feature had the same direction, with no significant outcome test. SOZ-AUC also did not differ by outcome. An exploratory control found a larger treated-channel fraction in seizure-free patients, which could lower D_RS. The study had low power, used short clips, pooled ablation and resection labels, and did not correct for treated volume. These results do not exclude small effects and do not test full-length recordings.
SEEG · epilepsy surgery · interictal activity · surgical outcome · resection · ablation · permutation test · OpenNeuro
References
5- supportsIn 34 HUP SEEG patients, interictal power, line length, and transient rate identified clinical SOZ contacts; montage differences were not significant sci:sha256:085d996653984a91bcf826588ef36abb841b8b8e1e79e0ff2f52724f36f15cdf
That work found that resection-zone AUC does not separate Engel I from Engel II-IV in 34 HUP patients. With a pre-registered composite score, a pooled two-cohort sample (43 patients, 4 centers) and a stratified permutation test, we also found no outcome separation (p = 0.16, direction opposite to the hypothesis).
- usesThe 30–45 Hz aperiodic exponent did not separate seizure-onset channels in 31 SEEG patients sci:sha256:970015c7ad657e77ac8f470146719405ea5536dba9b4dabf2cdf20f1f8c23615
Origin of the HUP (ds004100) per-channel interictal features and resection/SOZ labels that we used.
- usesIn 21 SEEG patients, resected non-SOZ channels were not more abnormal than non-resected channels sci:sha256:57d6bfb7b46bdd276988460f617e5faa2b676417e451ec4ee630686100bfb4cc
We used the two per-channel feature tables (HUP ds004100 and ds003876) archived in this package, without change, as the input features. Its limit 'no surgical-outcome split' defined our question.
- usesAcross 29 SEEG patients, the 30–45 Hz exponent did not separate SOZ channels, while four other features did sci:sha256:115bc8cb0b4c9e536b5f083843a2745508d3c6635a8156b661a9e084f51582a7
Origin of the ds003876 per-channel interictal features and resection/SOZ labels that we used.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds003876.v1.0.2
The analysis used archived per-channel features originating from OpenNeuro ds003876 v1.0.2. The publication identifies this release explicitly.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsInterictal SOZ AUC was not higher with good surgical outcomes across five SEEG centers
Treated-channel separation is not larger in seizure-free patients in 4 centers. Here the clinical SOZ separation is also not larger in good-outcome patients in 5 centers.