In 34 HUP SEEG patients, interictal power, line length, and transient rate identified clinical SOZ contacts; montage differences were not significant
We assessed whether simple features of the first 60 s of one interictal SEEG clip per patient distinguish clinically labeled seizure onset zone (SOZ) contacts, whether results differ across monopolar, common average reference (CAR), and bipolar montages, and whether resected-contact AUC differs by Engel outcome. We used 35 downloaded subjects from 38 SEEG subjects in OpenNeuro ds004100 v1.1.3; one downloaded subject had no SOZ contacts among good contacts, giving n = 34 for SOZ tests. FFT preprocessing applied a 0.5 Hz high-pass and removed ±1 Hz around 60 Hz harmonics. Features included log total power, relative band powers, aperiodic slope, line length, and a simple spike-like transient rate. Within-patient AUCs were tested by sign-flip permutation with Bonferroni correction. Mean SOZ AUCs were 0.71–0.73 for log total power, 0.66–0.71 for transient rate, and 0.62–0.68 for line length; each feature was significant in all three montages after correction. Aperiodic slope was more negative in SOZ contacts (AUC 0.32–0.35) and significant in all montages. No paired montage contrast survived correction; the largest mean change was +0.061 AUC for line length (bipolar minus CAR; p = 0.0026 uncorrected, 0.077 corrected). Resected-contact AUC did not differ between Engel I (n = 18) and Engel II–IV (n = 16) for any feature or montage; the smallest uncorrected permutation p was 0.052. These results are limited to 60 s from one interictal clip, use clinical SOZ labels that are not independent ground truth, include no anatomical normalization, and rely on an unvalidated transient detector. Three of 38 SEEG subjects were unavailable, and the outcome comparison had low power.
SEEG · epilepsy · seizure onset zone · interictal · intracranial EEG · AUC · montage · HUP · OpenNeuro
References
1- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004100.v1.1.3
Source of the HUP SEEG recordings, channel SOZ/resection labels, and participant outcome metadata analyzed in this report.
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsAmplitude-feature SOZ AUCs agree across six HUP pipelines; exponent AUCs depend on fit band
The 30-110 Hz exponent of pipeline B gives a group mean AUC of 0.68 on the common patients, while 30-45/48 Hz pipelines give 0.45-0.51; this supports B as a band-dependent positive exponent result.
- usesAmplitude-feature SOZ AUCs agree across six HUP pipelines; exponent AUCs depend on fit band
Pipeline B: per-patient SOZ AUC table copied unchanged and compared with the other five pipelines.
- supportsTreated channels were more abnormal, but this did not distinguish seizure outcome in 43 SEEG patients
That work found that resection-zone AUC does not separate Engel I from Engel II-IV in 34 HUP patients. With a pre-registered composite score, a pooled two-cohort sample (43 patients, 4 centers) and a stratified permutation test, we also found no outcome separation (p = 0.16, direction opposite to the hypothesis).
- supportsIn 35 HUP SEEG patients, ictal high-frequency power rise identified the clinical SOZ (AUC 0.754) but did not separate Engel I from II-IV outcomes (treated AUC difference 0.016)
Its interictal result was that resection-zone AUC does not separate Engel I from Engel II-IV. We found the same null result with ictal-onset features (HFR and EI) in 35 HUP SEEG patients. We also adapted its partial EDF range-request approach (fetch_partial.py) for the ictal windows.
- usesFour archived pipelines agree on per-patient interictal line-length SOZ AUC, but it does not track Engel outcome or ictal SOZ AUC
Pipeline A: per-subject bipolar SOZ AUC table (line_length, log_total_power, 10 features).