January-February warmth had positive links to the hazel-to-beech spring gap in western and eastern Switzerland in 1961-2020
We tested whether seasonal warmth had different links to hazel flowering and beech leaf unfolding. We used 3,753 matched station-years at 85 Swiss stations in 1961-2020. Four station-effect models split the records by region and period. Each year had equal total weight. January-February slopes for the time from flowering to leaf unfolding were +3.96 to +5.36 days per degree C. All eight-test adjusted intervals were above zero. March-April slopes were -0.57 to +0.15 days per degree C; all adjusted intervals included zero. Stricter station coverage and station trends kept the positive winter slopes. Bounded date errors of two days per event did not reverse the point slopes, but larger errors can do so. These are retrospective associations. They do not establish a causal climate effect, a long-term gap increase, or an ecological mismatch. Coarse weather, shared regional climate and missing visit records limit inference.
phenology · hazel · beech · seasonal temperature · matched stations · observation bias · Switzerland
References
9- reviewsA constant thermal-time model accounts for the change in leaf-out sensitivity to spring temperature at German and Swiss stations in 1951-2024; the 1999-2013 decrease did not continue in 2014-2023 sci:sha256:423c44cb2c725c9b8b27bc357201aab928313efb449fa8e132701bb85bd3292f
The prior Swiss leaf-out study motivates a matched two-species timing contrast. The source network overlaps; this is not independent data validation.
- doi:10.3389/fpls.2019.00398
- doi:10.5194/cp-20-659-2024
- usesdoi:10.1029/2007JD008470
- https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/dam/jcr%3A01ac0582-3132-462d-b96e-9d0066ba7ed8/Documentation_phenological_normal_periods_en.pdf
- useshttps://opendatadocs.meteoswiss.ch/a-data-groundbased/a9-phenological-observations
- https://opendatadocs.meteoswiss.ch/general/terms-of-use
- useshttps://psl.noaa.gov/data/gridded/data.ghcncams.html
- https://www.psl.noaa.gov/disclaimer/
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsMarch warmth had positive links to the beech-minus-larch emergence gap in four Swiss samples in 1961-2020
Related same-station seasonal contrast for hazel flowering and beech leaves. Source data partly overlap; no code reused.
- reviewsThe April-March temperature difference reduced later errors for birch and beech leaf date gaps in two Swiss regions, 2011-2025
The prior Swiss matched-event study tests winter and spring means for hazel flowering and beech leaf unfolding. We test monthly differences for two leaf events and later-year transfer. Some beech records and all weather sources overlap.
- reviewsApril warming relative to March had negative links to three-species leaf-out spans in four Swiss samples, 1961-2020
Prior paired-species seasonal response test in the same source archive; observations overlap.
- reviewsSpring warmth had no clear link to the elevation slope of the beech-hazel leaf date gap at 12 Swiss stations in 1981-2024
Prior hazel flowering versus beech leaf gap study uses overlapping network and weather; our hazel stage and elevation contrast differ.