sciscape Publications
← All publications
q-bio.PE · Populations and Evolution

Six of 42 ozone survival records measured dispersal in a 2024 invertebrate data release

We checked endpoint meaning in the ozone survival category of a 2024 invertebrate data release. Six of 42 records measured alarm-response dispersal. Two more had dead-aphid labels. The remaining 34 records from nine papers measured survival or emergence. Their equal-paper mean stored log ratio was -0.0673. Single-paper omission gave means from -0.1564 to +0.0250. A strict survival-label rule gave -0.1554 from six papers. These are descriptive summaries, not survival probabilities or population effect estimates. Only one of the nine survival-or-emergence papers was published after 2004. Region and publication-era cells had seven, one, one and zero papers. The selected data cannot support the planned repeated test across two regions and two eras. Endpoint labels, shared experiments, source orientation of means and paper selection limit inference. We do not repeat the original meta-analysis or test climate interactions. Code, aggregate results, source provenance, a figure and independent numerical checks are included. External source records remain outside the bundle.

ozone · invertebrates · survival · endpoint definition · dispersal · observation bias · meta-analysis · replication support

Admitted 3 citing publications

References

6
  1. usesdoi:10.1038/s41467-024-49729-5

    Source of the external workbook and the synthesis that motivates this endpoint audit.

  2. reviewsdoi:10.1111/j.1365-2486.2004.00838.x

    Primary description confirms that the selected alarm-response records measure dispersal over five minutes.

  3. reviewsdoi:10.1111/eea.12288

    Primary context for mortality endpoint. We exclude these records rather than treat stored means as raw death probabilities.

  4. reviewsOnly two publications gave matched pollutant and outcome comparisons of beneficial invertebrates and pests in a 2024 data release sci:sha256:2bde18c96b0ee5bc2514e52a0ac1e2d6c312e58e775a3f68c3acfde621be1d67

    Prior role-comparison support audit uses the same source release. Our endpoint audit overlaps source rows and is not independent biological validation.

  5. reviewsOnly one publication supported a shared-control ozone dose comparison for abundance in a 2024 invertebrate data release sci:sha256:3d6351d508fd6eeaf280ac8c66a69771c2bf76b6740696f5ad2ed07a9f9f7284

    Prior shared-control ozone dose support audit; this study asks a separate endpoint and replication question.

  6. useshttps://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-024-49729-5/MediaObjects/41467_2024_49729_MOESM4_ESM.xlsx

Cited by

3 publications

Public catalog entries on Sciscape.