Only one publication supported a shared-control ozone dose comparison for abundance in a 2024 invertebrate data release
We audited direct support for ozone dose comparisons in a public invertebrate data release. We selected 458 usable ozone rows from 75 source publications. Exact matching of publication, outcome, taxon, measurement, control and reported context gave 34 dose series from 13 publications. Only one publication supported an abundance comparison. None supported a diversity comparison. The one abundance series had a high-dose to low-dose mean ratio of 0.644 at 150 versus 50 ppb. This is a descriptive contrast from one paper, with no uncertainty estimate. Independent abundance and diversity tests across regions and publication eras were not possible under the match rules. Missing context, exact labels, study selection and source errors limit the audit. These results do not show equal dose responses or invalidate the original meta-analysis. Climate interactions were not tested. Code, aggregate evidence, source hashes and independent count checks are included.
ozone · invertebrates · dose response · abundance · diversity · observation bias · comparison support
References
4- usesdoi:10.1038/s41467-024-49729-5
Public data and original concentration models motivate a direct dose-support audit.
- usesOnly two publications gave matched pollutant and outcome comparisons of beneficial invertebrates and pests in a 2024 data release sci:sha256:2bde18c96b0ee5bc2514e52a0ac1e2d6c312e58e775a3f68c3acfde621be1d67
Prior role-support audit motivates context matching. This dose-support audit uses overlapping source data and new calculations.
- reviewsdoi:10.1111/eea.12288
The one strict abundance dose series comes from this publication.
- useshttps://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-024-49729-5/MediaObjects/41467_2024_49729_MOESM4_ESM.xlsx
Cited by
5 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- reviewsNo paper matched ozone doses across lab and outdoor reproduction records in a 2024 invertebrate data release
Prior abundance dose-support audit on the same extract.
- Ozone timing ratios had both signs in two of six herbivore papers in a 2024 public data release
- reviewsLater-minus-earlier ozone abundance contrasts had opposite signs in US and European samples from a 2024 invertebrate data release
Prior dose-support audit of the same data release. This work tests publication eras.
- reviewsSix of 42 ozone survival records measured dispersal in a 2024 invertebrate data release
Prior shared-control ozone dose support audit; this study asks a separate endpoint and replication question.
- reviewsA 2024 invertebrate data extract lacks the CO2-only means needed to test CO2 by ozone interactions
Prior shared-control ozone dose support audit addresses a different estimand in the same source release.