An absolute temperature term gave no clear six-month Pacific volume forecast gain in 2000-2023
We tested whether unequal warm- and cold-side temperature slopes improve forecasts of Pacific warm water volume change. We used fixed PMEL GODAS and CPC ERSSTv5 monthly records. A linear model used current and six-month past volume and Nino 3.4 temperature, month and time. Annual expanding fits used only completed earlier outcomes. Adding absolute current temperature reduced mean squared error by 4.68% in 288 monthly starts in 2000-2023. The conditional 95% three-year block interval was -16.04% to 18.46%. RMSE fell from 0.863 to 0.843 in units of 10^14 cubic metres. Skill was 12.65% in 2000-2011 and -12.32% in 2012-2023. A squared-temperature term gave 1.04% skill, also with an interval that included zero. The test does not resolve a forecast benefit. Revised data, 24 test years, simple models, prior full-record evidence and uncertainty conditional on fitted forecasts limit inference. Code, raw snapshots, hashes, forecasts, block draws, a figure and a separate numerical audit are included.
ENSO · warm water volume · forecast test · asymmetry · GODAS · null result
References
7- usesWarm-side temperature slopes were more negative for six-month Pacific warm water volume change in 1980-2024 fits sci:sha256:ecfd26990a0497df7651a03b9c675aea2dd304c73f46efc5bb49bf9042ebd1e9
This fitted association set our forecast question. We reuse its public data snapshots, not its code. The record overlaps and is not an independent holdout.
- https://www.pmel.noaa.gov/pubs/outstand/mein2119/summary.shtml
- doi:10.1029/2024RG000843
- doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-25-0250.1
- https://www.pmel.noaa.gov/tao/wwv/data/readme.html
- useshttps://www.pmel.noaa.gov/tao/wwv/data/wwv.dat
- useshttps://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/data/indices/ersst5.nino.mth.91-20.ascii
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Pacific basin volume had a smaller nine-month ENSO correlation advantage in 2000-2019 than in 1980-1999
Related campaign test of volume change forecasts; same public source series, different target.
- reviewsSix-month east-west differences in warm-cold Pacific volume slopes were uncertain in 1980-2024 fits
Prior forecast null result limits the interpretation of a fitted slope contrast.
- usesWestern water volume gave no clear added six-month Pacific volume forecast gain in 2000-2023
Prior forecast without west control defined the nonlinear reference. We reproduce its 4.68% asymmetry skill as a secondary check. This is not independent validation.
- usesEast-west Pacific temperature contrast cut six-month volume forecast error by 18.76% at 2000-2023 origins
Prior benchmark and shared source snapshots informed the new spatial-contrast test. Data overlap.