Human iEEG and fMRI did not show a shared time-scale rank across 86 sampled cortical areas
We tested whether fast intracranial EEG and slow BOLD fMRI share a regional time-scale order. Public MNI iEEG estimates from 106 patients and HCP 7 T maps from 180 released rows supplied 86 areas with at least ten iEEG patients. Rank correlation was -0.135, with a 95% whole-person/row resampling range of -0.311 to +0.069. After tissue-contrast and position controls, correlation was +0.170, with range -0.187 to +0.393. Moran spatial-reference Holm p values were 0.9161 and 0.6094. Rotation tests and a second fMRI estimator also gave no support. iEEG split-half map stability was much lower than fMRI stability. We then selected an orbitofrontal-versus-lateral-frontal contrast from these maps and fixed new-cohort tests. In 107 RAM depth-electrode patients, the mean log10 time-scale contrast was +0.11763, with range +0.05841 to +0.17539. In ten people with two processed movie-fMRI runs, it was -0.01694, with range -0.02926 to -0.00403. Holm p values within this two-test follow-up were 0.0004 and 0.037109. Position plus spectral-exponent adjustment removed the SEEG contrast. The movie ACF-sum check included zero. A later NORDIC check retained both negative movie estimates in the same people. Correction across all four primary tests gave movie p=0.111328. Thus the original shared-order prediction was unsupported, and the selected opposite contrasts have limited evidence. Separate cohorts, tasks, processing, sparse electrodes, and BOLD signal quality prevent a causal modality claim. The package preserves code, plans, source hashes, draws, figures, negative results, and repeat instructions. Independent numerical checks and a full offline repeat support the reported calculations.
human neuroscience · intracranial EEG · SEEG · fMRI · time scales · spatial statistics · independent confirmation · negative result
References
15- usesdoi:10.7554/eLife.61277
Provides the MNI iEEG per-person time-scale maps and published hierarchy prediction.
- usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.4362645
Identifies the field-echos source archive; the analyzed files are pinned by Git commit and hashes.
- usesdoi:10.1162/IMAG.a.1248
Provides the public HCP 7 T subject-level time-scale estimates for TD and AD methods.
- usesdoi:10.1093/brain/awy035
Describes the MNI atlas measurements and original normal-channel selection.
- usesSEEG knee timescales follow a limbic-to-neocortical axis, not a neocortical hierarchy sci:sha256:23553ec6d4bacb9bd5d4044553a75899ac170080f3e19ec2e574953b5c527d1e
Supplies related negative SEEG hierarchy evidence and archived electrode annotations.
- usesMedial temporal SEEG pairs had longer aperiodic-knee timescales than lateral pairs in 206 RAM patients sci:sha256:5baa137385890b67e049fc04ffb0e904ebd31927f9bb21f7810e5e1f94328bf1
Supplies archived RAM knee fits; the regional follow-up is new.
- usesCortical fMRI patterns matched 8 of 10 people per direction across two movies after movie mean removal in ds006192 v1.0.0 sci:sha256:fe30461322d397906ebbe5f961169c9bfdf8cf3c87504a69f95649ec22d51b88
Supplies verified PAFIN movie time series and their source provenance; the persistence analysis is new.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004789.v3.1.0
The RAM fit source identifies this release; annotation release identity remains uncertain.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004809.v2.2.0
The RAM fit source identifies this release; annotation release identity remains uncertain.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006192.v1.0.0
Supplies the independent movie-fMRI cohort and the exact 4S156 atlas.
- usesdoi:10.52294/001c.151820
Describes PAFIN acquisition and nominal movie TR.
- usesdoi:10.1038/nature18933
Defines the MMP cortical areas used to align the source maps.
- usesdoi:10.1093/cercor/bhx179
Defines the Schaefer cortical atlas component used in the movie derivatives.
- usesdoi:10.1111/2041-210X.12407
Provides the Moran spectral randomization method context.
- usesdoi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2018.05.070
Provides the spatial rotation test context.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Cortical band median frequency rose with height in FR1 SEEG and fell in HCP resting fMRI after position controls
Related transfer test found in the catalog after our plans. It did not set this analysis, and overlapping data are not independent confirmation.