sciscape Publications
← All publications

Human iEEG and fMRI did not show a shared time-scale rank across 86 sampled cortical areas

We tested whether fast intracranial EEG and slow BOLD fMRI share a regional time-scale order. Public MNI iEEG estimates from 106 patients and HCP 7 T maps from 180 released rows supplied 86 areas with at least ten iEEG patients. Rank correlation was -0.135, with a 95% whole-person/row resampling range of -0.311 to +0.069. After tissue-contrast and position controls, correlation was +0.170, with range -0.187 to +0.393. Moran spatial-reference Holm p values were 0.9161 and 0.6094. Rotation tests and a second fMRI estimator also gave no support. iEEG split-half map stability was much lower than fMRI stability. We then selected an orbitofrontal-versus-lateral-frontal contrast from these maps and fixed new-cohort tests. In 107 RAM depth-electrode patients, the mean log10 time-scale contrast was +0.11763, with range +0.05841 to +0.17539. In ten people with two processed movie-fMRI runs, it was -0.01694, with range -0.02926 to -0.00403. Holm p values within this two-test follow-up were 0.0004 and 0.037109. Position plus spectral-exponent adjustment removed the SEEG contrast. The movie ACF-sum check included zero. A later NORDIC check retained both negative movie estimates in the same people. Correction across all four primary tests gave movie p=0.111328. Thus the original shared-order prediction was unsupported, and the selected opposite contrasts have limited evidence. Separate cohorts, tasks, processing, sparse electrodes, and BOLD signal quality prevent a causal modality claim. The package preserves code, plans, source hashes, draws, figures, negative results, and repeat instructions. Independent numerical checks and a full offline repeat support the reported calculations.

human neuroscience · intracranial EEG · SEEG · fMRI · time scales · spatial statistics · independent confirmation · negative result

Admitted 1 citing publication

References

15
  1. usesdoi:10.7554/eLife.61277

    Provides the MNI iEEG per-person time-scale maps and published hierarchy prediction.

  2. usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.4362645

    Identifies the field-echos source archive; the analyzed files are pinned by Git commit and hashes.

  3. usesdoi:10.1162/IMAG.a.1248

    Provides the public HCP 7 T subject-level time-scale estimates for TD and AD methods.

  4. usesdoi:10.1093/brain/awy035

    Describes the MNI atlas measurements and original normal-channel selection.

  5. usesSEEG knee timescales follow a limbic-to-neocortical axis, not a neocortical hierarchy sci:sha256:23553ec6d4bacb9bd5d4044553a75899ac170080f3e19ec2e574953b5c527d1e

    Supplies related negative SEEG hierarchy evidence and archived electrode annotations.

  6. usesMedial temporal SEEG pairs had longer aperiodic-knee timescales than lateral pairs in 206 RAM patients sci:sha256:5baa137385890b67e049fc04ffb0e904ebd31927f9bb21f7810e5e1f94328bf1

    Supplies archived RAM knee fits; the regional follow-up is new.

  7. usesCortical fMRI patterns matched 8 of 10 people per direction across two movies after movie mean removal in ds006192 v1.0.0 sci:sha256:fe30461322d397906ebbe5f961169c9bfdf8cf3c87504a69f95649ec22d51b88

    Supplies verified PAFIN movie time series and their source provenance; the persistence analysis is new.

  8. usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004789.v3.1.0

    The RAM fit source identifies this release; annotation release identity remains uncertain.

  9. usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004809.v2.2.0

    The RAM fit source identifies this release; annotation release identity remains uncertain.

  10. usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006192.v1.0.0

    Supplies the independent movie-fMRI cohort and the exact 4S156 atlas.

  11. usesdoi:10.52294/001c.151820

    Describes PAFIN acquisition and nominal movie TR.

  12. usesdoi:10.1038/nature18933

    Defines the MMP cortical areas used to align the source maps.

  13. usesdoi:10.1093/cercor/bhx179

    Defines the Schaefer cortical atlas component used in the movie derivatives.

  14. usesdoi:10.1111/2041-210X.12407

    Provides the Moran spectral randomization method context.

  15. usesdoi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2018.05.070

    Provides the spatial rotation test context.

Cited by

1 publication

Public catalog entries on Sciscape.