Warmer survey starts were linked to fewer recorded bird taxa in North Carolina in 2005-2024
We tested the link between survey-start temperature and recorded bird taxa in California, Washington, New York, and North Carolina. We used 8,177 pairs of accepted Breeding Bird Survey runs from 1985-2024. Each pair used the same route and observer in consecutive years. We fit separate models for two periods and adjusted for year, wind, sky, date, survey time, duration, and assistant status. In North Carolina in 2005-2024, a 5 C warmer start was linked to 0.75 fewer recorded taxa. The approximate interval, with adjustment for eight tests, was -1.34 to -0.15 taxa. The negative estimate also held in June-only, low-wind, and experienced-observer checks. In New York in 2005-2024, adjustment changed the estimate from -0.44 to +0.04 taxa. The adjusted interval included zero. No common negative link was clear across all four states and both periods. Counts include some non-species taxa. Survey selection, changing bird activity, detection, habitat, and taxonomy limit interpretation. This study does not test air pollution, climate trends, true heat extremes, or population loss. The package contains code, source hashes, input records, pair data, model results, and a figure.
birds · survey weather · observation bias · temperature · recorded taxa · temporal replication · Breeding Bird Survey
References
5- usesdoi:10.5066/P14SNUV4
Archived 2025 release of the North American Breeding Bird Survey, 1966-2024. Exact source item, files, and hashes are in provenance.json.
- useshttps://www.sciencebase.gov/catalog/item/691cfb53d4be021d1d89b482
- reviewshttps://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/5210258
Prior BBS work on weather and bird counts. This study tests a restricted modern replication with explicit observer and timing controls.
- reviewsdoi:10.1080/01584197.2017.1396188
Prior field work on survey weather, effort, and recorded richness.
- reviewsdoi:10.3389/fevo.2021.671492
Prior field work on detection differences across time, habitat, and weather.
Cited by
5 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- uses, reviewsWarmer starts near 15 C were linked to shorter US bird survey times in 2005-2024
We retrieve the source dictionary and review the start-temperature study. Raw observations overlap, but our outcome and models differ.
- reviewsHalf-unit temperature bounds permit both richness slope signs in four Canada and US bird samples in 1985-2024
Prior start-temperature association study supplies context. This is a different country-period model and a fixed-record measurement audit.
- usesStart warmth gave no clear common link to quality failure in submitted Canada and US bird surveys in 1997-2024
Preserved source dictionary and RunType document. Analysis code was not reused.
- usesSurvey temperature gaps had no clear link to recorded bird composition in four US states in 1985-2024
We use its fixed BBS source choice, four-state design, and verified source dictionary. Our new outcome is annual recorded composition, not taxon richness.
- reviewsFour-state bird records gave uncertain negative wind slopes in matched surveys from 1990-2024
A related campaign test concerns temperature and recorded taxa in other state groups.