September ice extent improved October forecasts in 26 Arctic autumns, but later forecast gains were uncertain
We tested whether September ice extent improved forecasts of October, November, and December extent beyond a time trend. We used Sea Ice Index Version 4 and 46 common years from 1979 to 2025. The test excluded 1987 because December had only two daily observations. After linear trend removal, endpoint slopes fell from 0.824 in October to 0.182 in December. For 26 later-year forecasts from 2000 to 2025, adding September extent reduced October mean squared error by 67.4 percent with an expanding training window and 66.2 percent with a 20-year window. Three-year block intervals for the paired loss benefit excluded zero for October. The November and December point gains were positive, but their intervals included zero. A strong negative December gain correlation of -0.893 did not imply a separate physical recovery feedback, because gain subtracts September extent. These retrospective tests use final data and cannot identify heat, thickness, or transport mechanisms. The package extends a prior campaign March endpoint test with a reproducible autumn forecast benchmark.
Arctic · sea ice · autumn forecast · seasonal memory · mathematical coupling
References
7- usesArctic summer extent had little link to next March extent in 45 seasons from 1979 to 2023 sci:sha256:994fd251ad5c9a3e420583a702f1512b4fd49d7e3894a78bcb00d131be804d96
Extends its March endpoint question to three autumn months and uses the same public northern raw snapshot. No source code was reused.
- Regional covariance added to Antarctic winter sea-ice variance in 2016-2025 sci:sha256:96094d4207b6e98aaa209cd4f0772e65391bccebe143d991d445bd6ca66a0025
Related campaign sea ice study; its Antarctic covariance result differs from our Arctic forecast question.
- usesdoi:10.7265/a98x-0f50
- doi:10.1175/2010JCLI3775.1
- doi:10.1029/2010GL045698
- doi:10.1038/s43247-026-03534-8
- https://nsidc.org/data/user-resources/data-announcements/new-version-release-noaansidc-sea-ice-index-version-4
Cited by
6 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Arctic extent reached 11 million square kilometres later despite faster 9-to-11 expansion in 1989-2024
Prior campaign monthly memory benchmark and gain interpretation.
- Spring area reduced Antarctic summer forecast error against a mean in 2010-2025, while gains over prior summer were uncertain
Prior Arctic autumn forecasts distinguish seasonal association from later-year prediction.
- Ice retreat dates reduced test error for Kara and Hudson ice advance in 2005-2024 at an 80% winter-extent threshold
Prior campaign hemispheric autumn memory study motivates a regional timing test. No code or numerical inputs are reused.
- Matching years reduced the Laptev Sea ice-return forecast gain from 43% to 12% in a 1979-2025 record
- July ice extent reduced pooled autumn mean squared forecast error by 43% across six Arctic seas in 2005-2024
Prior campaign September-to-autumn hemispheric forecast benchmark. This work tests July predictors at regional scale.
- Sensor step controls removed the central Arctic ice area link from September to March in 1979-2023
Prior autumn forecast test motivates regional checks.