Across-channel noise correlations limited linear SEEG decoding in 8 subjects
We tested whether across-channel trial-to-trial noise correlations limit linear decoding of rest versus key press from stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) band power. Using archived features from 8 subjects in OpenNeuro ds004473 (snapshot 1.0.2), we trained shrinkage linear discriminant analysis on trials 1–100 and tested on trials 101 and later. Within each class and split, independent channel-wise trial shuffles preserved each channel’s means and variances while removing across-channel noise correlations. For high-gamma features (70–150 Hz), the shuffled condition increased held-out AUC in 7 of 8 subjects (mean difference +0.047; exact two-sided sign-flip p = 0.023). For high-gamma plus beta features (13–30 Hz), the increase was +0.076 (7 of 8; p = 0.016). On held-out trials, noise variance along the training class-difference axis exceeded the independent-channel value in all 8 subjects (mean log ratio 1.17, approximately 3.2-fold; p = 0.0078). Full-covariance LDA did not recover the loss for high-gamma features (diagonal minus full LDA mean AUC difference −0.007). The shuffle is a counterfactual, and some AUC increase may reflect easier covariance estimation. Noise includes drift, state change, and volume conduction, which were not separated. The study includes 8 subjects from one task; secondary tests were not corrected for multiple comparisons.
stereo-electroencephalography · noise correlations · linear decoding · brain-computer interface · high-gamma activity · shrinkage LDA
References
2- usesBeta power increased later-trial SEEG key-press AUC in 6 of 8 subjects sci:sha256:b76113878b22b13b8fce6b4b57cf321bb22ce16b618b55ae02c2ef42b972f816
We used the archived ds004473 per-trial HG and beta bipolar features (all trials, 8 subjects), the trial split and the numpy shrinkage LDA code of this publication.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004473.v1.0.2
The archived features used for this analysis are identified as derived from OpenNeuro ds004473 snapshot 1.0.2; their feature-file hashes are preserved in original/results/input_sha256_features_04683a2a.txt.
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesPretrial Rest Does Not Predict Movement-Window Decoder Noise in SEEG Key-Press Data (8 Subjects)
Source of the question: it found shared noise on the decoder axis. This work tests if that noise continues from the pre-trial rest window into the movement window.
- In 7 of 7 ds006253 patients, shared 70-150 Hz SEEG noise placed about 3.3 times more variance on the movement axis; linear drift did not explain the effect
[Legacy relation: reproduces] We reproduce the main finding (noise on the signal axis larger than the independent-channel value, and AUC increase after a within-class shuffle) in a second dataset, ds006253 (7 of 7 patients, log ratio 1.20, p = 0.008). We also show that linear drift does not explain it.
- usesResidual covariance terms for face-house contrasts had opposite signs before spatial centering in 7 ECoG patients and 6 fMRI participants
Its projected variance ratio in a motor SEEG study provides a method precedent. We add signed components and test separate visual ECoG and fMRI studies.