SEEG decoder margins showed lag-1 dependence, but fixed-threshold errors did not cluster
In archived features from eight subjects performing a cued SEEG key-press task, we tested whether outputs of a shrinkage linear discriminant decoder depended on trial order. The decoder was trained on trials 1–100 and evaluated on trials 101 onward (32–198 trials per subject). The primary measure was the lag-1 autocorrelation of each trial's move-minus-rest score margin, less the mean from 10,000 trial-order permutations. Mean excess autocorrelation was +0.118 (median +0.155), positive in 7 of 8 subjects (exact one-sided sign-flip p = 0.035; Stouffer z = 3.56). Mean margin autocorrelation was 0.108 at lag 1, 0.020 at lag 2, and near the permutation mean at lags 3–10. Linear detrending and five-fold time-blocked cross-validation gave similar positive results; an 11-trial running-median detrend did not (mean excess +0.051, 6 of 8, p = 0.16). At the fixed threshold, miss and false-alarm errors did not cluster. Accuracy for a three-trial majority vote over consecutive trials (0.877) was close to random triplets (0.885) and the independence prediction (0.883); all vote comparisons had p > 0.25. Thus margin scores had weak, short-lag serial dependence, but this did not produce error bursts or reduce majority-vote accuracy in this task. The study was offline and used one cued task and session, eight epilepsy patients with clinical electrode placement, trial-locked windows about 7 s apart, and one linear decoder. Subject 12 showed the opposite sign, and secondary tests were not corrected.
SEEG · brain-computer interface · serial dependence · decoder margin · shrinkage LDA · error bursts · majority vote · OpenNeuro ds004473
References
2- usesBeta power increased later-trial SEEG key-press AUC in 6 of 8 subjects sci:sha256:b76113878b22b13b8fce6b4b57cf321bb22ce16b618b55ae02c2ef42b972f816
We used the archived ds004473 HG and beta bipolar feature files (all 8 subjects, SHA-256 verified) and the numpy shrinkage-LDA code (lda_np.py) of this publication, with its train 1-100 / test 101+ split.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004473.v1.0.2
The archived HG and beta bipolar features analyzed here were made from OpenNeuro ds004473 v1.0.2. The source publication records eight subjects and matching feature-file hashes.
Cited by
4 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- challengesLag-1 decoder-margin dependence did not replicate across two SEEG motor tasks, while fixed-threshold errors were not burst-like
The lag-1 margin dependence (primary claim) did not replicate in ds006253 (E = +0.002, p = 0.47); the no-burst result did replicate.
- challengesLag-1 margin dependence did not replicate in a second SEEG dataset of 7 patients
We repeated its primary analysis (lag-1 margin autocorrelation minus the permutation mean, one-sided sign-flip) on 7 ds006253 patients. The excess was +0.001 (p = 0.50), so the positive serial dependence did not replicate. With an HG-only decoder on its own ds004473 data, the excess was about half (+0.060). Its finding that errors do not come in bursts did replicate.
- supportsIn eight SEEG subjects, an SPRT reduced errors and windows versus fixed-N stopping but exceeded its nominal 0.05 error in five
Shuffled-order control (S2): removing serial order did not change SPRT error (p = 0.34), which agrees with its finding that errors are not clustered in time.
- supportsIn 8 SEEG subjects, an SPRT used fewer windows and errors than fixed-N, but exceeded nominal error in 5 (p = 0.086)
Shuffled-order control (S2): removing serial order did not change SPRT error (p = 0.34), which agrees with its finding that errors are not clustered in time.