Pre-report SEEG high-gamma activity weakly predicted confidence and added little to behavior in five patients
We tested whether 70–150 Hz SEEG high-gamma activity (HGA), measured before a confidence scale appeared, predicted later confidence ratings and added information beyond behavior. The analysis used archived epochs and behavior tables from five patients (180–300 trials each) performing a random-dot motion decision task. A prewritten plan specified patient-wise ridge regression on log HGA from four 150 ms windows around the response, five-fold cross-validation repeated five times, and Spearman correlation of out-of-fold predictions with confidence. HGA predictions were positive in four of five patients (median rho = 0.067); three patients had permutation p < 0.05, but the exact group sign-flip test was not significant (p = 0.125). Behavior alone had median rho = 0.374. After control for behavior, median partial rho for HGA was −0.002 (p = 0.375), and adding HGA increased rho in one of five patients. In correct trials, median rho was 0.039 (p = 0.19). HGA predictions correlated negatively with response time in three patients, consistent with much of the HGA read-out reflecting timing or motor-vigor information. The result is limited to five patients, whose clinical electrode coverage was not targeted to metacognition areas; the null group result does not establish absence of an effect. The archived work supports at most a weak confidence read-out from pre-report HGA, with little added information beyond behavior in this sample.
confidence · high-gamma activity · SEEG · response time · ridge regression · brain-computer interface · decision-making
References
3- usesIntracranial high-gamma activity showed weak, non-significant error decoding before confidence reports in five patients sci:sha256:4d0fdab1b79379b8d08092aae595035688a23a4470647de18416efc37249b63f
We reuse the archived binned HGA epochs, behavior tables, patient selection and trial selection of this publication, without changes.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds006253.v1.0.3
The analyzed HGA epochs and behavior originate from OpenNeuro dataset ds006253, version 1.0.3 (MetaRDK). The importer record identifies this exact version and records its CC0 license.
- doi:10.1101/2024.03.23.586414
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsIn 15 SEEG patients, pre-click high-gamma activity weakly predicted later confidence but did not improve behaviour-only ridge prediction (mean rho 0.107; Holm p=0.0024; delta -0.188)
With n = 15 instead of 5, we get the same small effect size (median rho 0.077 vs 0.07), which is now significant (Holm p = 0.0024). We also find, as 27ecc591 did, no added value over behaviour in a simple model.
- usesSEEG high gamma did not reliably decode changes of mind in four patients
Same dataset and HGA band; this publication uses change of mind only as a behavior covariate. We decode it from HGA.
- supportsIn 15 SEEG patients, pre-click HGA did not predict confidence beyond behavior
Same question with 15 instead of 5 patients and a drift null; again HGA adds no information to behavior.