SEEG high gamma did not reliably decode changes of mind in four patients
We tested whether 70–150 Hz high gamma activity (HGA) in stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) could predict or detect changes in mouse movement direction during random-dot motion decisions. In four patients from OpenNeuro ds006253 with at least 15 change-of-mind trials, we used within-patient L2 logistic regression, five contiguous time-ordered folds, and 500 label permutations. Median out-of-fold AUC was 0.515 before movement onset (−0.5 to 0 s; three of four patients above 0.5; group p = 0.44, Holm p = 0.44) and 0.538 during the first second after movement onset (three of four above 0.5; group p = 0.19, Holm p = 0.38). No patient had permutation p < 0.05; the highest was 0.628 (sub-23, post-onset; p = 0.056). HGA did not improve on a behavior model of coherence, movement latency, and correctness: median AUC gain was −0.007 before and +0.004 after movement onset. Exploratory no-fit movement-latency AUC was 0.609–0.648 in the four patients, with slower starts accompanying changes of mind. These results do not establish that the brain lacks a change-of-mind signal. They are limited by four patients, sparse trials, dataset-defined change labels, incomplete epochs, different event timing, possible motor signals in the post-onset window, and uncorrected exploratory analyses. The smallest possible one-sided exact group p-value with four patients was 0.0625.
stereo-electroencephalography · high gamma activity · change of mind · brain-computer interface · mouse movement · motion decision · cross-validation · negative result
References
3- usesPre-report SEEG high-gamma activity weakly predicted confidence and added little to behavior in five patients sci:sha256:cd5a7e8fdaaa3257d89e78b42b802f63c3b776bbd83a712e3f830143ba6ab7ce
Same dataset and HGA band; this publication uses change of mind only as a behavior covariate. We decode it from HGA.
- usesPre-click SEEG high-gamma weakly decoded choice; error-trial transfer favored choice in 4 of 5 patients but was not significant sci:sha256:84fde8f9c4b2d9617e34436f4ed963daac194cd54d5e2efa519a803dad2fd98b
Same dataset; left/right choice decoding before the click. We decode a change of the choice during the movement.
- usesIntracranial high-gamma activity showed weak, non-significant error decoding before confidence reports in five patients sci:sha256:4d0fdab1b79379b8d08092aae595035688a23a4470647de18416efc37249b63f
Input data: 50-ms HGA epochs and behavior files of OpenNeuro ds006253, and the epoch extraction method.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- supportsPre-click SEEG high-gamma activity detected change of mind but added no demonstrated value beyond kinematics in 15 patients
In 15 patients, HGA before movement onset and in the 0.5 s after it did not detect a change of mind. This agrees with the 4-patient null result. A pre-click signal exists, but behaviour fully explains it.