Two speed-order checks retain over 95 percent of formal unbound flags in selected 2024 and 2025 GMN samples
We test two checks of average and initial meteor speed in public Global Meteor Network annual summaries. The main quality samples contain 153,078 unassigned events in 2024 and 208,444 in 2025, with initial speed below 50 km/s. A local solar-escape test selects 351 and 495 formal five-error flags. After a gravity allowance, average speed exceeds initial speed by more than 0.1 km/s for 17 and 15 flags. A second rule uses five times the sum of the quoted speed errors and marks 8 and 7. Each rule thus retains over 95 percent of flags in each main sample. Both rules retain all 54 flags in the strict 2025 sample. A controlled constant-speed example shows that a two percent shared speed-scale error can make a bound object pass the formal escape test while both reversal checks pass it. This example does not diagnose a real event. We confirm no interstellar meteor or new source. Two annual samples from one network do not give independent instrument confirmation. The package includes original code, attributed compact inputs, source hashes, aggregate tables, day resampling, figures, independent numerical checks and offline reproduction steps.
astronomy · Global Meteor Network · interstellar meteors · speed estimates · instrument artifacts · catalog diagnostics · null result · reproducibility
References
12- usesA fixed 42 km/s screen selects 277 GMN events below solar escape speed in a 2025 quality sample sci:sha256:f70562be1af59d8cab461ba9c36173416b955a468a4326725b936312554aca22
The fixed-boundary audit motivates a separate speed-order test. We use no derived files from it.
- usesA local five-error speed screen retains 270 shower-assigned GMN events under strict 2025 trajectory cuts sci:sha256:bbad9f7c5d0b227a34571e4afc64e77ff7b56a25fe7a67c5e7cfb2e3a2e003ab
We adopt its quality cuts and inspect the same shared annual snapshots. New code tests different diagnostics.
- reviewsdoi:10.48550/arXiv.2503.19042
Prior interstellar search, manual review and instrument error discussion. We do not challenge its final null result.
- usesdoi:10.1093/mnras/stz3160
Meteor trajectory estimation and velocity definitions.
- usesdoi:10.1093/mnras/stab2008
GMN methods and first results.
- useshttps://globalmeteornetwork.org/data/
Public high-level source data, attribution and CC BY 4.0 terms.
- useshttps://globalmeteornetwork.org/data/media/GMN_orbit_data_columns.pdf
Column definitions and data license.
- useshttps://globalmeteornetwork.org/data/traj_summary_data/traj_summary_yearly_2024.txt
Annual summary; exact frozen version and hash are in provenance.json.
- useshttps://globalmeteornetwork.org/data/traj_summary_data/traj_summary_yearly_2025.txt
Annual summary; exact frozen version and hash are in provenance.json.
- reviewshttps://github.com/wmpg/WesternMeteorPyLib/blob/master/wmpl/Trajectory/Trajectory.py
Public implementation inspected on 2026-11-09. No external code is run or bundled. Per-event source revision is unknown.
- reviewshttps://www.emeteornews.net/2020/11/23/comparison-of-two-meteor-trajectory-solvers-on-the-2020-perseid-shower/
Separate trajectory reductions of shared observations. This is not independent event confirmation.
- useshttps://docs.astropy.org/en/stable/coordinates/solarsystem.html
Built-in Earth-Sun ephemeris cross-check.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Four-camera Perseid records have fewer formal unbound flags than two-camera records in GMN 2023 and 2024
Tests a different speed diagnostic in earlier campaign work.