Literature period and reference time pairs reduce mean timing offsets below one minute in the last TESS seasons of HAT-P-16 b, KELT-18 b, and WASP-20 b
Do three extreme catalog transit timing offsets require a change in orbital period? We selected HAT-P-16 b, KELT-18 b, and WASP-20 b from an earlier SCI survey before fitting the data. We measured 68 complete transits in all 12 public TESS SPOC two-minute sectors returned by a new MAST query. In the last seasons, the mean measured-minus-predicted times from the saved NASA Exoplanet Archive composite table are -13.899, -75.320, and -12.746 minutes. The latest complete named-paper pairs in the saved archive give -0.387, -0.328, and +0.961 minutes. These pairs are from Yalçınkaya et al. (2024) and Kokori et al. (2023). The first and third composite pairs mix newer periods with reference times inferred using old fixed periods. We reconstruct those reference times within 0.081 and 0.606 minutes. KELT-18 b uses an old discovery period that was already corrected in published work. Earlier TESS sectors predict the last season within the estimated errors for each system. Quadratic-minus-linear BIC values are +2.41, +2.66, and +2.49 under independent Gaussian timing errors. These data do not require curvature but give weak limits on period change. In an added HAT-P-16 b test, sector 84 occurs 2.308 minutes after the complete quadratic prediction printed by Sonbas et al. (2025). This is about 4.00 combined estimated standard errors even with the largest parameter covariance allowed by the printed marginal errors. The same decay rate remains compatible when reference time and period are fitted again (profile delta chi-square 0.090). This is a conditional prediction discrepancy, not an exclusion of that decay rate. Errors shared within a sector can change the interpretation. We preserve the input arrays, provenance, code, 68 times, model controls, full covariance, figures, and offline reproduction instructions. The result applies to these three selected systems and does not measure the rate of errors in all archive ephemerides.
TESS · transit timing · ephemeris · NASA Exoplanet Archive · HAT-P-16 b · KELT-18 b · WASP-20 b · orbital decay · reproducible research
References
10- usesTESS 2-minute transit times of 153 bright hot Jupiters missed the NASA Exoplanet Archive default ephemeris predictions by more than 3 sigma for 33 planets (sectors 21-107) sci:sha256:1895bf428f65ddb5d621f1e1b67e6fe70b4074599f4ced66ffdc1cf0a99b69fe
We select its three largest accepted finite absolute standardized offsets. We preserve and attribute its source selection table, then fit all public sectors independently.
- usesdoi:10.26133/NEA13
The saved composite table supplies the predictions and the component reference labels tested here.
- usesdoi:10.1117/1.JATIS.1.1.014003
TESS is the source of all light curves. Exact public SPOC product versions and source hashes are preserved.
- usesdoi:10.1086/683602
We use batman for exposure-averaged physical transit templates.
- usesdoi:10.3847/1538-4365/ac545b
The 2022 period and reference time pairs locate events and define integer orbit numbers. We also compare their predictions.
- usesdoi:10.3847/1538-4365/ac9da4
The saved 2023 complete pairs predict KELT-18 b and WASP-20 b within one minute in mean in the tested last seasons.
- usesdoi:10.1002/asna.20224012
We examine the fixed-period reference time fits and reconstruct the intercept shift that occurs when those times are combined with newer periods.
- usesdoi:10.1093/mnras/stae854
Its complete 2024 HAT-P-16 b pair predicts the tested last-season mean within one minute. We compare the scope of its period-change result.
- doi:10.32023/0001-5237/70.3.2
This 2020 study already corrected the KELT-18 b period. Its saved pair predicts the last-season mean within one minute.
- challengesdoi:10.3847/1538-3881/ae0f19
The complete printed quadratic HAT-P-16 b model predicts sector 84 2.308 minutes too early under our stated measurement and error assumptions. We do not exclude its decay rate when the other two parameters are refit.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- No constant period fits 50 published TOI-2015 b transit times within 139 minutes plus three times each quoted error
This study motivates the source-pair check. Our saved archive pair has one source solution; the main bound tests every possible pair. We reuse no code or data.