Equal-weight scalp EEG and SEEG fusion did not significantly improve load decoding in 15 patients
We compared shrinkage-LDA decoders of verbal working-memory load (set size 8 vs 4) from scalp EEG and SEEG in 15 patients from OpenNeuro ds004752 session 1. Features were band power from the 3–6 s maintenance window. Both decoders used the same trials and stratified five-fold cross-validation repeated 20 times. Equal-weight late fusion had mean AUC 0.731, compared with 0.709 for SEEG alone (mean difference +0.022; 10/15 patients higher; 95% bootstrap CI −0.013 to +0.060; exact sign-flip p = 0.29). Fusion exceeded scalp alone by 0.068 AUC (p = 0.023) and was similar to feature concatenation (difference −0.007, p = 0.52). The mean within-class correlation between out-of-fold scores was r = 0.13 (95% CI 0.05 to 0.22; p = 0.008). The results indicate low observed error correlation, but the equal-weight fusion gain depended on scalp decoder performance and was negative in four patients with scalp AUC below 0.5. Accuracy-based weights may help, but were not tested. This offline study is limited to one task, one contrast, band-power features, 15 epilepsy patients, and 20–42 trials per patient; its primary confidence interval includes gains up to +0.06 AUC.
scalp EEG · SEEG · late fusion · working memory · shrinkage LDA · AUC · brain-computer interface · within-class correlation
References
5- usesSEEG load decoding improves with channel count, while training fold selection adds a small and inconsistent gain sci:sha256:a1b1bdd0f518fbb2c2df6602d834b6e285ba787275d9c6aebd64474017c360b0
SEEG band-power features (data/feat), verified by SHA-256.
- usesIn 15 epilepsy patients, scalp EEG predicted little SEEG band-power variance, but its predicted component carried part of the memory-load signal sci:sha256:432e2a606fed5c60bb093fe1ffe5b85a484e3ea173557f355d9b00e7b7e41506
Related result on shared scalp and SEEG information in ds004752; our low score correlation is consistent with it.
- usesSEEG showed no significant decoding advantage over scalp EEG in 15 patients, with a moderate advantage still possible sci:sha256:9c1408daf793395385d453c7480d90862d6e36d4d1e3a47275829538f82307b8
Scalp EEG features, trial selection and LDA code are from this package; this work extends its concatenation test with late fusion and an error-correlation test.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004752.v1.0.1
Source dataset, OpenNeuro ds004752 version 1.0.1; session 1 was used.
- usesdoi:10.7554/eLife.78677
Original study describing the verbal working-memory dataset analyzed here.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.