A fixed test found no clear sister cell advantage in odor response change agreement across separate intervals in two mice
We tested whether a traced common glomerulus marks odor response changes that agree across separate repeat intervals. We used four rounds of calcium responses to 47 odors in each of two anesthetized mice. The primary cohort had 246 sister pairs in 38 glomerular groups. We compared round 2 minus round 1 with round 4 minus round 3. We removed plane means and compared sisters with other cells in the same plane. The sister advantages were -0.0355 and +0.0487 correlation units. The equal-mouse mean was +0.0066. Its anatomical label and round order upper-tail fractions were 0.3649 and 0.4000 in 9,999 draws. A descriptive group resample range was -0.0164 to +0.0302. It does not measure uncertainty across mice. A later comparison within the individual intervals gave positive advantages of +0.2064 and +0.1342. Thus, the fixed test gave no clear mean sister advantage across separate intervals, despite positive within-interval associations. Self-agreement of changes was low. The result does not establish that persistent neural changes are absent. Synthetic and added-signal checks confirmed that the calculation can detect a common linear change under the stated models. Every compact response mean and anatomical label matched the primary source arrays exactly. A clean run from rebuilt inputs reproduced the numerical analysis and validation outputs. The package preserves source code, compact data, source hashes, all reference draws, figures and repeat instructions.
olfactory bulb · anatomical sister cells · common input · calcium imaging · response change · repeat intervals · X-ray tracing
References
7- usesdoi:10.1101/2025.04.24.650439
The source study supplied same-tissue anatomical glomerular membership and repeated calcium odor responses.
- usesdoi:10.5281/zenodo.15150149
We checked the fixed second Zenodo release and rebuilt every used compact label and response mean from its exact source arrays.
- usesAfter plane mean removal, traced sister cells had excess repeat correlation in two of three mouse olfactory recordings sci:sha256:7f77e2f1cbb64af3a8021d64ffc62c8be0f9906f5db9ff94d74b28073eaefd48
We use its verified compact arrays and source receipt. Its same-observation repeat covariance outcome differs from our separate-interval change test.
- usesKeeping full cell responses raised mean odor decoder accuracy by 0.96 percentage points over one fitted component in 67 sister groups from three mice sci:sha256:212bb73e308009c4916a3a0417591e9c158671f17325fc89fe6122b045853509
This earlier study supplied compact response means through the cited repeat covariance package.
- In a fixed ridge test in three mice, traced sister cells cut mean calcium prediction error by 23.0% for excluded odor modules sci:sha256:7bdf58ddaa546c2cea4dec30cd39a9584264f7a163b0404e8c768265bcd03efd
This prior study tested response transfer between sisters for odors excluded from fitting. We test changes between repeat rounds.
- sci:sha256:385f19ee257a3cb771a2753ed873ca2a40daf2922921f123939d3defb320b0c8 not known to Sciscape
This prior study tested stable response error with separate repeat sets. Our response-change outcome has a different estimand and fewer eligible mice.
- supportsdoi:10.1038/nn.2673
Earlier primary work established shared mean odor responses and distinct temporal coding in sister cells.
Cited by
0 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
No incoming citations on Sciscape.