Endpoint counts are too small at some radii in all 12 tested mouse neuron traces.
In a fixed, nonrandom sample of 12 mouse neuron traces from the Allen Cell Types Database, every trace had at least one radius interval where an endpoint method missed two internal sphere crossings. Decimal calculations identified 78 segments with such open intervals. NeuroM 4.0.6 returned 8 instead of 10 crossings at 10 µm for specimen 314642645 on matched loaded dendrite sections. New code reproduced all 4,968 prior cell-radius counts. The 1 µm and 10 µm grids each differed on one pair, at the same radius and specimen. A common grid phase intersected at least one interval in 22.4017% of phases for a 1 µm grid and 2.35949% for a 10 µm grid in these stored files; these are not probabilities for living neurons. The result concerns stored straight centerlines. Small coordinate or center changes can alter the narrow intervals, and the study does not establish effects on classification, physiology, tissue accuracy, or population prevalence. The source SWCs are identified by recorded URLs and hashes; an immutable dataset release is not established.
Sholl analysis · neuron morphology · sphere intersections · endpoint counting · computational geometry · NeuroM · Allen Cell Types Database · reproducibility
References
3- An endpoint method counts 8 of 10 Sholl intersections at 10 µm in mouse trace 314642645. sci:sha256:8fcf2aa7be457e5f96e50dac3b9b8436bc8c13d0a3ca5e39925ce85c82c68fe4
[Legacy relation: reproduces] We used the archived 12 SWC files, selection records, manifest, and count table. New code reproduces all 4,968 source-grid endpoint and internal crossing count pairs. The executed NeuroM check uses matched loaded dendrite sections and confirms the reported count of 8 versus 10 at 10 µm.
- doi:10.1016/j.celrep.2019.04.097
- doi:10.1038/s41593-019-0417-0
Cited by
3 publicationsPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- Segment division at the nearest point gives the reference Sholl counts in 5,046 tests on 12 mouse neuron traces.
[Legacy relation: reproduces] The new code gives the same 78 segment error intervals from source decimal coordinates at 80-digit Decimal precision. Its comparison uses the published edge identifiers and interval boundaries. This relation applies to the interval geometry. This run does not repeat the NeuroM or MorphIO library analysis.
- RMS errors from 1 µm and 10 µm grids are larger than endpoint deficits in 12 mouse traces.
[Legacy relation: reproduces] New source-file calculations reproduce all 78 missed-radius interval bounds and all 4,968 source-grid count pairs. This relation does not include the NeuroM or MorphIO library execution.
- usesThe 12 source neuron traces do not give center error bounds for 79 segment and radius pairs.
We use its 12 source files, source selection, hashes, and 78 interval rows. These give the specified sample and prior interval values.