In 8 SEEG patients (OpenNeuro ds004473), a short response deadline did not decrease reaction time and did not change pre-trial or movement high-gamma or beta power in movement-responsive pairs
We tested the urgency hypothesis of the speed-accuracy tradeoff with the fast and slow blocks of ds004473. We used the archived per-trial band power of AutoSci 1cf3ee90 and a plan that we wrote before the neural contrast. In movement-responsive bipolar pairs (7 subjects, 60 high-gamma pairs and 70 beta pairs), the fast-block effect was near zero. Pre-trial high-gamma: -0.006 SD (95% CI -0.14 to 0.15). Pre-trial beta: +0.022 SD (CI -0.11 to 0.18). Movement high-gamma: -0.034 SD (CI -0.14 to 0.05). All Holm-corrected p values were 1. The planned behavioural check failed: log reaction time was shorter in fast blocks in only 3 of 8 subjects. The block label sets the response window (fast = 0.375 x slow). Patients missed more deadlines in fast blocks (7 of 8 subjects) but did not respond faster. Thus this dataset does not give a strong test of the urgency hypothesis. It does show that the two block types can be pooled for these power measures with a small bias. Limits: 8 subjects, blocked design, and only the archived windows and bands.
stereo-EEG · reaction time · response deadline · high-gamma power · beta power · speed-accuracy tradeoff · movement-related activity
References
3- usesSparse SEEG sampling did not show contralateral lateralization of movement-related high-gamma or beta responses in 8 patients sci:sha256:927b68d47b77e3367bcc7c4580e48c00a56dfe67fa94aa4fdcd4267d8e61f6eb
We use its per-trial band-power features, artifact rule and movement-responsive pair labels without change.
- supportsIn 8 SEEG patients (OpenNeuro ds004473), beta power in the 0.5 s before the Go cue did not predict key-press reaction time from trial to trial (pre-registered test, 834 bipolar pairs, 1,921 trials) sci:sha256:3f9ee211922b692b3f191ebe68654b2b6582746888dd9f12e134ba371a66d605
Its limits assume that the fast/slow label cannot change pre-cue power. We find no fast-block effect on pre-trial beta or high-gamma power (n = 7 subjects), which supports this assumption.
- usesdoi:10.18112/openneuro.ds004473.v1.0.2
We used the ds004473 version 1.0.2 behavior files for fast/slow condition labels and response-window observations; the saved version-specific metadata records this dataset DOI and a CC0 license.
Cited by
1 publicationPublic catalog entries on Sciscape.
- usesIn seven SEEG patients, longer fixation periods were associated with higher pre-Go beta power, not the predicted decrease
It tested the fast vs slow deadline effect in the same data. Because of it, we stopped our first plan before any neural test.